'^^k^

<'^"

'W?^

i^. *'■ -*7;

'4^ -4

>• >

5^rjf*>K- 1 -

%^^

^N*"

vV^

'>*Bn^

.-^-.v

^'^■■

* ■ ' • V.

■•\-t

/^./U

• ^

!--J*

f^o^^ V

*** .,,j^:j.^v- ;■

Hii^^''^*^

u. '-'^ '"■••,-ry^ 'Iv-. • ^'-^j

:^-/^bi^

■^'it^

.<;-, r>

X.IW-^'

A Practical Journal of Railway Motive Power and Rolling Stock

INDEX FOR VOLUME XIV, I9OI.

Illustrated articles are marked with an asterisk ("'■).

Accident, Curious, 241.

Extraordinary Crossing. 47u. .\ccidents in Miciiigan. 8U. .\cetylene Gas. 75.

Gas Headlights, 71. Address of Fres. Morris :u .Master Mechanics'

ConTention, 319. •Adjuster, Ali-free Cut-ott', 179. AdTertising and Write-ups, 119. -iir. Saving Compressed, 156. .^ir Brake :

Abnormal Short Stops, 314. Address by Mr. Rhodes, 313. •Adjustable French Braise, 313. .\ir Gages, Improved, 124. Hose. 490. Signal Puzzle, 360. •Pump, Eleven-Inch, 532. .Association Convention, 256. •Automatic Air Brake, ti.v F. 1". Darte, 83 •Air Coupling. 4S9. •Drain Cock, 489. •Auxiliary Air Pump. 315. •Boring Bar for OVi-Inch Pump, 82. Brake Beam Lever Interferes, 315. Beam Hanger Inclination, 127. •Cylinder Cleaner, 216. •Piston Replacer, 489. ♦Shoe FriCLion, 172. •Shoes, 124. •Valve, New York, 125. Valve Repairs. 80. Broken Reversing Piston, 173. Check Valves. Leaky, 261. •Cleaning Cylinders and Triple Valves, 401.

of Brakes. Fictitious, 261. Compressed Air. 4S9. Convention, 169. •Coupling, Automatic, 489. •Dummy. 445. •Hose, 12.5. •Cylinders. Location of Driver Brake. 446. •Darte's Automatic Brake. 83. •Device for Emptying Oil Barrels. 315. 446. •for Testing Yard. 216. •Triple Valve Holding. 30. I'isorders. Triple Valve. 27. •Double Heading. Device for Brake Valves.

445. •Drain Cock. Automatic. 489. •Driver Brake for Lehigh Valley Engines, SO. •Brake Cylinders. Location of, 446. •Dummy Coupling. 445. •Eight-Inch Pump for Supplying Driver

with Air. 301. •Electric Brake with Combiueil Kail and

ANheel Shoes, 169. •Eleven-Inch Air Pump, 532. Feed Water with .Mr I'umii lOxliaust, 79. Fictitious Cleaning of Brakes. 2111. Fitting Triple Piston Packing Rings, 173. Force at Different Speeds. 173. •French Adjustable Brake, 313. •Friction. Brake Shoe. 172.

•Ring for Rotary Valve Key. Metal. S3. Hand Brakes on Partiallv Equipped Trains,

445. Heating Feed Water with Air Pump Ex- haust. 79. High Pressure Trouble, 316. Hold Heavv Trains Without Brake. 171. Hose. Air. 490. •Coupling. 125.

•Without Kinks or Dirt in It. 172. Ice in Train Pipes. 123.

Increased Price for Cleaning Triple Valves and Brake Cylinders, 357.

Air Brake :

•Indicator. Pressure, 172.

Improved Reversing Plate, 533.

•Inside Hung Brake on Passenger Car

Truck, 83. Inspection Needed on Eastern Roads, 123. Inspectors and Good Train Handling, Effi- cient, 124. •International Correspondence School Chi- cago Plant, 25. Leaks, Train Pipe, 30. Leaky Check Valves. 261. Lehigh Valley Driver Brake, SO. •Leverage, 213, 259, 357, 399, 443. 487. 531. Levers, Misplaced Brake, 316. •Lofy & Ettinger's Chart, SI. •Main Reservoir Location, 215.

•Reservoir on Top of Boiler. 316. •Marea's Separating Device, 29. •Metal Friction Ring for Rotary Valve Key, 83.

Packing Ring for Brake Valves. 83. •Metallic Air Hose and Coupling. 363. Misplaced Brake Levers. 316. •New York Brake Valve. 125. •New York, Susquehanna cSc Western In- struction Room, 170. Perforated Casing for Air Pump, 217. •Piston Bush in Valve, Worn, 125. •Pressure Indicator, 172.

•Retaining Device, 314. •Pump, Auxiliary Air, 315.

Sling. 83. Questions and Answers, 31. 84. 128. 174, 218, 261, 317, 361. 406. 447. 491, 534. Refitting Triple Valve Packing Rings. 27. Release Port, Suggested Enlargement of

Full, 26. PLepairs of .Mr Pumps. 361. Itetarding Force of Brakes, 80, 81. S3. 215.

261. •Reversing I'late, Ch.inge in, 490. 533.

•Valve Rod Remover, 30.

with Brakes Applied, 171. •Separating Device. Marea's. 29. •Slack -Adjuster, Westingliouse, 29. •Sling for .\ir Pumps. S3. •Southern Pacific Testing Cart, 533. Steam Heat Kink. 127. Stops. Abnormal Short, 314.

•Two Application. 25, 28. •Storeroom in Westinghouse Works, Hamil- ton. Ont.. 123. •Strainer for Pump, 316. •Testing Cart, Southern Pacific, 533.

Cleaned Triple Valves, 81.

•Yard Device. 216. •Test Rack at Hamilton. Ont.. 79. Train Pipe Leaks. 30.

Stopping Conditions. 30. 530. Triple Valve Disorders. 27.

•Valve Holding Device. 30.

Valve Packing Rings. Refitting, 27.

•Valves. Device for Testing Cleaned. St.

Valves. Release Test for, 127. Two Air Pumps. 534. ♦Two-Application Stop, 25. 28. •Valve Rod Remover, Reversing, 30. Water Brake on Mountain Grades, 445.

Freezing in Train Pipes. 126.

♦Jacket for Air Cylinder. 489. Westinghouse Electric Brake and Heater. 374.

•Instruction Car, 256.

•Officials. 530.

•Slack Adjuster, 29.

•Test Rack, 79. Worn Out .\ir Pumps. 361. .Mr Brake Instructor. Pioneer. 266.

•Jacks. 480.

Pump Exuaust. Disposing of, 36S.

•All-free Cut-off Adjuster, 179.

American Citizens in Mexico, Outrages on, 395.

Locomotive Company, 365.

Society of Mechanical Engineers. Increas ing Dues of, 482. Angle Cock, Trouble with Frozen, 154. Apprentice, Defense of, 70.

Machinist, 38.

System, 13. Arithmetic. Railroad. 102. •Armstrong Planer Tool. 137. Ash-pan, Self-Dumping, 476.

Slutted. 476. .\sh Pans. Self-Cleaning. 522. •Atlas Tube Expander, 36S. -Attachments. Inconvenient Location of. 151. •Australian Railroading, 388. Auxiliary Cut-off for Locomotives. 475.

•Quadrant. Schaefer's, 347.

Quadrant is Old, 3S7.

•Reverse Lever, 347.

B

•Ball 'Joints. Grinding, 231.

Joints, Steam-Pipe, 168. •Bausch Boring Machine, 45. Bearings. Electric Theory of flot. 160. 2Imi

Hot and Cold, 3.

Journal, 106. •Becker-Brainerd Milling Machine. 130. •Bell Frame. Tool for Boring Holes in. Uo.

The Locomotive, 107.

Yoke. Hand Boring Bar for, 245.

Yoke Reamer, 478. Blacksmith. Traveling. 108. •Blacksmithing, Railroad. 112. Blow Hard to Locate, 195. Boiler Maker, Traveling, lOS.

Makers, Amateur, IIS. Boilers. Blowing Off Before Washing Out. 106.

•Laying Out Slope Sheet, 348.

Locomotive on Steamboat, 113.

New Locomotive, 105.

Overworked. 161.

Test of Locomotive. 16.

To Prevent Foaming, 107.

•Vanderbilt. 57. Bolts. Nuts. Cotters and Split Pins. 162. Book Notice, 19, 77, 253, 356. 440. 4S4. 527. •Boring Bar for Bell Yoke, 245. 'Boston Terminal Yard, 105. •Boston's New Water Supply, 510. Box Cars. Height of Grain Load Lines. 348. Boxes. Bad Practice with Hot. 197.

Hot, 143.

Electric Theory of Hot. 160. 200. •Bover's Shop. 236. ♦Buffalo Shops. 231. P.urners. High and Low Pressure, 386. I'.reakdowns. 69.

Examination on. 343. Breaking of Cylinder Packing Rings. 365. Bridges. Cement. 468. •Briil Semi Convertible Car, 309. British Railway Officials, 512. •Broken Piston Rods. 468. Brooklyn Elevated Returns to Steam. 348.

•Cab .Arrangements of Plant Engines. 190.

Fixtures. Inconvenient. 408. Caledonian Railway Engines and Cars. 163. •Calking Strips for Firebox, 73. Canal. Soo Power. 464. Car Couplers. Diversity, IS.

.Tournal Bearings, 143.

•Replacer. Snow. 265.

Shortage, 52.

99446

,.R4U^WAY..,\ND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERINC.

Carbon Uioxidu, Climatic Influence on, 396.

•Carnegie, Andrew, ISl.

Cars. EaUier uf.CaJMo, ,110^., ,.,o,„uc ., ,..

H^glit of 'f-jtainihoaC' iSn^s ip, g-t§{ .;

King; uf .Spain-s. -41) u ; , ' - - - <

Lo'a(S oT tn^iisn Ffeiglit, 522. ' '

New Standard Car, o2U.

*New Zealand Passenger. 60.

•North Coast Limited, 277.

Painting Steel, 41S.

Pressed Steel, 227.

Pressed Steel, for .Spain, 356.

Pressed Steel, in Egypt, 255.

Pres. McKinley's Funeral. 450.

•Semi-Convertible, Brill, 309.

Sullivan Handy, 230.

•Vandi-rbilt Steel Hopper. 492.

Ventilating Passenger, 439. •Cart. Handy Push. 274. •Castings, Tropenas Process of Making, 24. Cellar. Packing Driving-box, 70. Cement Bridges. 46S. •Central of New Jersey Indicator Diagrams,

385. Centrifugal vs. Steam Jet Blowers. 188. •Changing Valve Motion, 432. Chesapeake & Ohio Shops, 311. Chester Steel Tie, 308.

•Chicago & Nortnwestern Itoundhouse at Clin- ton, la.. Heating the, S.

•& North Western Shops at Clinton. la.. 263. China's Need of Locomotives, 96. Christensen Engineering Co., 514. • •Chuck for l-^ccentrics, 274.

•for Holdius Rod Keys. Turret, 340. Clearance Lights. 163. Club Meeting, New York Railroad. 280. Coach Heaters. 67. Coal, Poor. 117.

Cock, Trouble with Frozen Angle, 154. Cocks, Cylinder, 140, 252.

Drain, 302. Coke Burning. 197.

•Collision. Result of Dynamite in, .Ul. Colors. Signal. 484. Combustion and Heat, 334, 373. 397. 4.S.">.

Spontaneous. 302. Comfort. Loyalty and Economy. 146. Compressed Air. Saving. 156. " Compressor Works. Franklin. 129. Conductors' Long Runs. 514. •Connecting Rod. 310. •Convention. Mechanical Engineers'. 3]0.

Notes. 320, 324.

Traveling Engineers'. 441. 381. Conventions. Railwav Mechanical. 4. Copper. Lost .\rt of Hardening, 353. Couplers. Diversitv of Car, IS. •Crank Pin Oiler. 521. Crossing Accident. 470. •Crown Bolts. 295.

Sheet Failed. 12. ♦Cuban Raihv.iys and Rolling Stock, 2i;,'i. ♦Curvature "1' Track, Sharp, 387. •Cut-off. Phelps Riding, 70. ♦Cylinder Frame and Brace, Dickson's. 201. Cocks. 140. 252.

•Oiling. .'123.

or Piston-Ring Friction. 476. Packing Rings. Breaking of. 365. Cylinders. Uneven Wear of. "llO. Warm. Keeping. 306.

D

Davis Wheel Center, 50. Device for Prevening Train Robbery, 440. Devices. Mistakes with New. 396. ♦Dickson's Cvlinder Frame & Brace, 201. Drait Gear. Service Tests. 499.

Master Car Builders Tests. 525.

To Investigate. 17.

•Westinghouse Friction, 20. Drain Cocks. 302.

♦Drawbridge Delaware, Lackawanna & West- ern, 176, Driving Boxes, Hot, 527.

Wheel Tires. Flattening of, 386. ♦Dunbar's Packing Rings. 88. ♦Dust Guard, Harrison, 50.

•Eberhardt, Ulrieh, 223. ♦Eccentric Chuck, 274,

•Rods, 342,

Straps, Care of, 151. Eccentrics, Hot, 73. Education. Technical. 354.

vs. Overtime. 494. Educational Training for Railwav Service. Electric Headlights. 352, 478.

•Theory of Hot Boxes, 200, Electrical Power, Transmitting, 303, Electro-Magnetism in Machine Work, 513. •Elevated Electric Train, 4. J-;ikhart Drawing School, 193.

Tunnel, Ventilating. 326. Employes. Overworked Railroad. 480. Engine. Hopkins Pneumatic Auxiliary, 18. •Engine-House. Plant System, 200. •Engineer's Torch, 297. Equalization, Poor, 252,

•European Railway Notes, 48, 94, 166, 237,

323, 366. 409. 469. .'Examination for Promotion, 19, 104, 248,

; 333. 391, 497.

; ,.* from Traveling Engineer's Standpoint, 346. on Breakdowns, 343. of Locomotive Engineers, 76. Questions. Catch. 75. Exhaust Disposing of Air Pump. 368. •Exhibit, Lunkenheimer. 436. •Exposition, Glasgow, 254. 328, 423. Erie Shops. 308. 338.

Shops at Buffalo, 114.

•Fay & Egan Planer, 460.

Feed Water at Different Seasons, 12.

Fire Kindler. Hydro-Carbon, 2.

Fires. Banking of. 297.

Firing, Is Smokeless, Practicable, 242.

Locomotive. 10.

Machine More Effective Than Hand, 264.

Smokeless, 106.

Smokeless, on Pacific Coast, 242. •Floods on North Eastern Ry. of England. 11. ♦Flue Cleaner. Rossell's Flexible. 266.

Cutter. 294.

•Plant. 327.

♦Welder, Hankin's. 198. Franklin Compressor Works. 129. Freight. Tank Track, 527, Friction, Cylinder or Piston Ring, 476. Fuel. Firing Liquid. 3 37.

♦Oil in Locomotives, 300.

o

Gas. Acetylene, 75. Gauge in Ohio, 42. Gear. Investigate Draft. 17. General Electric Display at Pan-American, 415.

Electric Lighting Exhibit, 436. •Glasgow Exposition. 254, 328, 423. Graphite Steel, 191, Grate Areas, 467,

and Heating Surface, 191, •Grinder, Heald, 86. ♦Grinding Ball Joints, 231.

•Machines. Norton, 270.

Piston Rods. 113.

H

Hancock Injector. Double Check for, 188. •Hankin's Flue Welder. 198. Hardening Steel. 87. •Harrison Dust Guard. 50. Headlight, Acetylene Gas, 71.

Covering, 429, 521.

Electric. 352, 478.

Good, 483. •Heald Grinder, 86. Heat and Motive Power. 485. •Heater for Piston Valve Bushing, 64. 432. Heaters for Coaches, 67.

•Heating Chicago & North Western Round- house, 8.

Hot Blast. 139.

Trains with Exhaust Steam from Air Pump. 99. Help Between Engineer and Fireman, Mutual.

204. •Helwig Pneumatic Air Motor, 192. Hopkins Pneumatic Auxiliary Engine. IS Hot Boxes. 143.

Driving Boxes, 527.

and Cold Bearings. 3. High and Low Pressure Burners. 386. •Hughson Joint. 372. Hydro-Carbon Fire Kindler. 2.

•Indian Workshops. Work Done in. 517. Indicator Diagram, Lessons of the Steam, 250.

•Central Railroad of New Jersev, 385,

•Star. 501, Information, Absorbing. 382. •Injector, Double Check for Hancock, Com- posite, 188.

*Wm. Sellers. 247. Inspection. X-Ray, 67. Inventions. European Press on American 411

Impracticable, 162.

Needed Connectabilitv. 117.

•Jacks. Air, 480.

Jacketing of Steam Cylinders, 524.

•Japan. Railroading in. 32.

•Joint, Hughson, 372,

•Journal Bearings, 106.

•Boxes. Packing. 196. •Journals. Wear of, 37.

Lead Help an Engine to Start, Does, 350, Lever, Auxiliary Reverse, 430. •Lighting Set, Sturtevant, 371.

Train, 47. Lights. Clearance. 163.

Dangerous .signal, 163.

Something .\bout, 37. Link Motion, Defence of, 11.

Motion and Switch Engine, 69.

•Motions, 528. •Linstrom's Eccentric Straps, 153. Liquid Air as a Motive Power, 115.

Fuel, Firing, 137. Locomotive Boiler, 105.

•Goes, Why the, 65. Locomotives :

Against Heavy. 108. American, in India, 412.

vs. English, in India, 520. ♦Atchison, Topeka & Santa Fe, 101. •Atlantic Coast Ten-Wheeler. 39. •Auxiliary Engine for, 414. •Baldwin Atlantic, for France, 493.

•Atlantic Type for Germany, 62.

•Compound, for Union I'acioc, 303.

•for Bismark, Washburn & Gt. Falls, 509.

•for Buffalo. Rochester &. Pittsburgh, 497.

♦for New Zealand, 437.

•for Illinois Central, 247,

♦for i-ehigh Valley, 249,

•for Pike's Peak, 40S.

•Mogul, for Pennsylvania, 356.

•Ten- Wheeler for St. Paul Ry., 540.

•Union Pacific, 10. •Baltimore A: Ohio Tandem Compound. 448. •Belgian, 6S.

Big Engines and Big Ships. 483. Big, Has Attained Limit, 113, •Bismark, Washburn & Gt, Falls, 509. Boiler Tests. 16.

•Boston & Maine Consolidation, 139. •Buffalo, Rochester & Pittsburgh, 535. •Burlington. Cedar Rapids & Northern, 1. Brooks "Chautauqua" for Buffalo, Roches- ter & Pittsburgh, 530,

•for Burlington, Cedar Rapids & Nor- thern, 1.

♦for Pere Marquette, 235.

♦Oil Burner for San Pedro. Los Angeles i Salt Lake, 467. •Caledonian .Mineral, 456. •Canadian I'acific, Built by Canadian Loco.

Works. 114. •Catskill Mountain, 502. •Cape Government, 90, *131. •Chicago, Milwaukee & St, Paul, 540. •Cleveland, for Inter-Colonial, 341. •Coahuila & Pacific, 87, ♦Competition of English and American,

341, Compressed Air, 101, ♦Cooke, for Coahuila & Pacific, 87,

•for Oregon Short Line, 103.

•International & Great Northern, 51.j.

•Mogul for Ontario & Western, 233.

•Southern Pacitic Ten-Wheeler, 145. ♦Copiapo, 397. •Delaware, Lackawanna & Western, 193,

•219, •379. ♦Ueuver & Rio Grande Compound. 289.

•307. ♦Details of "Copiapo." 523. •Dickson Mogul for Grand Trunk. 203. •Dubs' Narrow Gage, 191. Dutch. 475.

•State Railway. 299. •Early New lOngland, 46. Economical Load of, 116, 151. English Engineers' Views on American, 344.

•Suburban. 383. Firing, 10.

•First Pittsliurgh. 13. •German Four-Cylinder Compound, 120. •Grand Trunk Mogul. 203. •Great Western Express, 238.

Western Single Bogie Express, 66. Growth of. 385. •Highland Ten-Wheeler. 5. •Hinckley & Drury, 66. •Illinois Central Ten-Wheeler, 247. In China, 94.

Indian Official on American. 350. •International & Gt. Northern, 515. •Irish, 430.

•"La Parisienne," 32o, •Lehigh Valley Consolidation, 249, •Michigan Central Ten-Wheeler, 23, •17."i. •Midland Express. 240. •Mineral, for Caledonian, 456. •Minneapolis, St. Paul & Sault Ste. Marie.

38. •New York Central Atlantic Type, 337,

•391. •New Zealand, 437. *494. •North Eastern Ten-Wheeler. 189. •Northern Pacific Tandem Compound. 381. Norris, 479.

Observing Details of. 428. •Oil Burning, 300, *454. •Old Chilean, at Pan-American, 397. Ontario & Western, 364.

•& Western Mogul, 233. I'au .\merican Exposition. 389.

RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERLXG

Locomotives :

•PennsylTania Mogul, 3ui;.

•Pere Marquette "Chautauiiua," lioS.

Performance of Large, 71.

Philadelphia & Ueadlng Consolidation, 245.

•Pittsburgh, for Pittsburgh & Western, 168.

•tor India, 2G9.

•Tandem Compound for Baltimore & Ohio. 4iS. •Plant Keciird P.reaker, 240. Power of. 204. :i01. •Porter Compressed Air. sll. •Rhode Island, for Santa Ke. 101. •Kichmond. for Atlantic Coast Line, 39.

•for Denver & Rio Grande, 289.

•for .New Zealand, 494. Rating Capacity of, 52tj. Relative Merits of British and American,

304. •Road, 61.

•San Pedro. Los Angeles & Salt Lake, 467. •Schenectady, for Boston & Maine, 159.

•for Michigan Central, 23.

•for Cape Government, 90, 'ISl.

•for Delaware, Lackawanna & Western,

•for New York Central. 337.

•for "Soo" Line. 38.

•Tandem Compound, for Northern Pa- ciQc. 381.

•Ten-Wheeler tor .Michigan Central, 175. •South Eastern A: Chatham. 237. ♦Southern Pacific Ten-Wheeler, 145.

•Pacific. That Pulled Presidential Train, 339. Standard Classification. 305. Strength and Weakness of Compound, 72. •Test of Plant, 164. Too Big for Bridges and Tunnels. 509. •Type of 1850, 105. •Union Pacific, 10.

•Pacific Compound, 30:!.

•Pacific, with Vanderbilt Koiler. 57. Valuable Attachments, ■■j17. Why Compound. 228. •Worsdells Ten-Wheel Express, 189. Lubrication of Heavv Locomotives. 243.

of Piston. 523.

of Valves. 243. •Lubricator. Filler for, 129.

Improved Oil Box, 161. •Lunkenheimer Exhibit, 436.

M

Machinist. .Apprentice, 38.

Traveling. 108. Main Rod. Why Take Down, 198. Master Car Builders' Draft Gear Tests. 525. Mechanical Engineers' Convention, 310. Mexican <Jutrages vs. American Citizens, 484. •Michael's Improved Pass-by Valve, 242. Microbes, 118.

Mileage of British Engines, 500. •Milling Machine. Becker-Brainard. 130. Mistakes in Application of Engine Mechanism,

482. Molding Machines. Perfected, 539. ♦Mood's Original Pop Valve. 107. Motion. Defence of Link. 11. •Motor, Helwig Pneumatic Air, 192.

Hot Water, 18.

N

Nashville, Chattanooga & St. Louis Air Brake

Maintenance. 439. New York Railroad Club Meeting, 280. •New Zealand Passenger Cars, 60. •North Eastern Railway of England, Floods

on, 11. •North Coast Limited Cars, 277. •Norton Grinding Machins, 270. •Nozzle, Effect of Altering, 477. Sweeney, 109,

Officials Need Training. 77.

Oil Box Lubricators. Improved, 161.

•Cup. New Pressure. 183.

•Fuel in Locomotives, 300.

House. Terminal Railway In St. Louis. 26.'!.

Preventing Waste of. 182.

•Pump. Hand. 139.

The Coming Fuel. 371. •Oiler. Crank Pin, 521.

•Steam Chest and Crank Pin. 521. •Oiling. Cylinder, 523.

Wedires. 76.

Packing, .\gainst Steam Piston,

Driving-Box Cellar. 70.

•Journal Boxes, 196.

Ring. 801.

•Rings. Dunbar's. SS. Painting Steel Cars. 418.

Pan-American Notes, 382.

Parson Turbine Engine. 354.

Passes. -Annual Effort to Abolish, 525.

Peary's Letter to Mr. Moore, 456.

Perfected .Molding Machines, 539.

Personals. 43, 92. 135. 177, 185, 221, 267,

369. 407, 419, 451, 495, 537. Pensioning, Three Ways of, 252. Performance Sheet That Lies, 440. •Phelps' Riding Cut-off, 70. Pickled Railroad Ties. 435. PLstiin Lubrication. 523.

•Rods, Broken, 468.

Rods, Grinding, 113.

Valve Bushing, Heater for, 432. •Planer, Block for, 274.

•Tool, Armstrong Bros., 137.

•Spur Clamp for. 274. •Plant Engine Cab Arrangements, 190.

Locomotive Speed. 477.

S.vstem, Destiny of, 364.

•System Engine House, 200.

System Speeds. 145. Pooling of Locomotives, 58, 65. 153, 239, Port Drainage Cocks. 344. Porter. Lament of the, 439. Posts. Clearance. 118. •Presidential Trip to California, 290. Pressed Steel Cars. 227, 255. Producing Power of American Mechanics.

perior. 513. Progress of 1900. 44. Promote the Practical Men, 395. Promoting by Favor. 251. Promotion, Examination for, 19, 104,

391, 497. Prophecies of Daniels, 96. •Pump. Hand Oil, 139.

•Vollowstone National Park, 477.

•Rack. Steel. Woodward & Powell, 312. •Railroad Blacksmithing, 112.

Life Educational Effect, 513.

•Loschwitz Suspension, 343.

•Sandv River. 429. Railroader, Old Time, 14. Railroading, Australian, 388,

Comparison of American and English, 433.

Early. 108.

English and American, 518.

•in Alabama, 345.

•in a Reservoir, 510.

*in .Japan. 32.

in .Mexico. 299. Railroads. Building, in African Wilds, 339.

Encouraging Future of, 74.

History of. 5. 141.

in Japan. 296.

Operation of English and American, 438.

Storekeeping, 296. Railway Meclianical Conventions, 4.

•Notes, European, 48. 94, 166, 237, 323, 366. 409, 469.

Service. Educational Training for, 2.

•Trans-Siberian. 147, 224, 471. Railways in Spain. 138.

of the World. Governmental. 514.

Interests. Community of. 526. Rates Too Low. 17. •Reamer, Bell Yoke, 478. Recorder Called the Chronograph, 536. Recording Devices. 185.

•Relief Valves tor Piston- Valve Engines, 476. Reminiscences of Early New England Roads,

15, Reporting, Mechanical, 141. •Richmond Compound Valve. 242. Rigid and Flexible Center Trucks, 17. •Rivet Head Cutter. 199. Road Supervision. Some Ideas on, 21. ♦Rocker Arm Bolt Puller Rings, Usefulness of

Retaining, 353. •Rod Bolt Puller. 349. ♦R<jds. Eccentric. 342.

•Turning and Grinding Piston, 370. Roofing. Ruberoid, for Arctic Exploration,

364. •Rossell's Flexible Flue Cleaner, 266. Roundhouse Organization, 438. •Roundhouse Tools. 479.

S.ofety of Trainmen, Promoting, 60.

of Railroad Men, 132. •Sandy River Railroad. 429. •Saw. Car Shop, Fay & Egan. 417. Scale Preventer, Sliger's, 372. •Schaefer's Auxiliary Quadrant, 347. Schenectady Locomotive Works, 181. School. Elkhart Drawing. 193. Scotland. Notes from. 380. •Scrap Shears. 234. Seeing Things. The .\rt of. o94.

Self-Cleaning Ash-pans, 522.

Self-Dumping Ash-pan, 476.

Sellers' Injectors, 247.

Sh.il't. Broken Driving, 109.

•Sli'-aring Attachment, 275,

•Slh-ars. Scrap, 234.

•Shoes and Wedges, Tools for Laying Out,

194. •Shop Notes and Ducks, Hunting for, 541.

Tools, 340. Shops Along the Erie. 308, 338.

•Boyers', 236.

•Chicago & North Western, at Clinton, 263.

Erie, at Buffalo, 114.

Huntington, Chesapeake & Ohio, 311.

•Lehigh Valley & Lackawanna, at Buf- falo, 231.

•Notes by Mr. Colvin, 277.

Railroad Notes by R. T. Shea, 274.

Scrap, 54.

•Two Harbors. 541. Side Rods Up on Engine En Route, 414.

Rods. Why Take Down Both, 14. Signal Colors, 484.

Lights, Against White, 77.

Lights. Dangerous, 163. Signals That Are Difficult to See, 515. Slack in Long Freight Trains, 440. Slotted .Ash-pans. 476. •Snow Car Replacer, 265.

•Fighting, 350. Soo Power Canal. 464. Smokeless Firing, 106.

Firing on Pacific Coast, 242.

Firing is Practicable, 242. Spark-Throwing by British Locomotives, 219. Speed of Plant Locomotive, High, 145, 477.

of Trains. 347. Spider. To Detach a Loose. 154. 196, 243. Spouts. Inconvenient Water. 394. •Spring, Device for Removing Driving, 202. Standard Time. 60. •Steam Chest Oiler. 521.

Cvlinders. Jacketing of, 524.

Pipe Ball Joints. 168.

•Pipe. Favors One. 154.

Piston Packing. -Against. 72.

Providing Plenty of. 160.

•Turbines. 39. 89.

Virtue of High Pressure. 252. Steel and Iron at Dangerous Temperatures. Working, 251.

Boiler Tubes. 330.

Graphite. 191.

Preparation of, and Points on Harden- ing. 87. Stacks. Diamond and Straight. 155.

Lining. Dislodged. 241. Storekeeping. Railroad, 296. Story, ".A Ghostly Tale." 355.

by F. M. Nellis, 426.

by D. H. Mvers, 460.

by R. E. Marks. 8.

"Conversion of Don Enrique,'' 34.

"Rough on Engineers." 516. Straps. Care of Eccentric. 151.

•Lindstrom's Eccentric. 153. •Strips for Firebox. Calking, 73. •Sturtevant Generating Set, 547.

Lighting Set. 371. Suburban Road Troubles. 310. Sullivan's Handy Car. 230. •Swedish Locomotives Fighting Snow, 195. Sweeney Nozzle. 109. System. .Apprentice. 13.

Tank. Provide Better Filling Features. 364.

•Reservoir on Top of, 154.

Track, Freight. 527.

Vanderbilt, 345. Technical Education. 354.

(Graduate. Advice to, 158. Telegraphy, Wireless, 161. Tenders with Water. Pilling, 431. Terminal Yard, Boston, 155. •Threading Tool, 340. Throttle Sketches. 69.

•Valves. 15, 53. 152. Throttling. 75. Time. Standard. 60. •Ties. Chester Steel. 308.

Pickled Railroad. 433.

Railroad, 351. Tires. Does Running with Full Throttle Flat- ten. 344.

Flanged, 159.

Flat. 389.

Flat Spots on. 197.

Flattening of Driving Wheel, 386.

Removing Hard Spots from, 103.

Testing Wear of. 273, 297. Tonnage Rating on Canadian Pacific, 77.

Rating for British Railways. 433. •Tool Holder for Slotting Machine, 340. Tools and Engines. New. 269.

•for Boring Holes in Bell Frame. 110.

for Laying Out Shoes and Wedges. 194.

•for Railroad Shops, 340.

•Roundhouse. 479.

•Threading. 340.

Transmuting I'ower bv Eiectricitv to Shop. 396.

RAILWAY AND LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING

•Torch, Engineer's. -VT,

Tractive Power, 233.

Train Despatching by Telephone, 411.

•Electric Elevated. 4.

Fastest of the World, 52.

•Fort Wayne Route, 504.

Lighting. 47.

Put Driving Wheels in, 433.

Robber Killer, Automatic, 158. 440.

Unimportant, 111. Trainmen. Overworked. 483. Transmitting Electrical Power. 303. •Trans-Siberian Railway, 147, 224, 471. Traveling Blacksmith. Boiler Maker and Ma- chinist, IDS.

•Engineers' Convention, 381, 441.

Engineers' Examination. 340. Triple Valves and Brake Cylinders, Increased

Price for Cleaning, 353. •Tropenas Process of Making Castings, 24. Trucks. Rigid and Flexible Center, 17.

•Rigid vs. Swing Center Car. 244.

Swing Center. 118.

•Wright's Pedestal Spring. 536. •Tube Expander, Atlas, 368. Tubes. Best Length of Boiler, 305.

Favor Steel Boiler, 330. Tunnel. Ventilating Elkhart, 326. •Turbines, Steam, 39. 89. •Turning Tool for Tumbling Shaft, 340. •Turret Chuck for Holding Rod Keys. 340.

•Valve, Broken. 157.

Drain, 243.

Lubrication of, 243.

•Michael's Improved Pass-by, 242.

•Mood's Original Pop, 107.

•Motion, Effect of Changing, 432.

•Motions, 157, 272, 349, 448.

•Plan for Balanced, 197.

•Relief for Piston-Valve Engine. 476.

Relief for Ports. 201.

•Richmond Compound, 242.

Setting, 117.

Test for Leaky Throttle, 196.

•Throttle, 15, 53. •Valves and Seats, Peculiar Wear of. 390. •Vanderbilt Boiler, 57.

•Steel Hopper Car, 492.

Tank, 345. Ventilating Passenger Cars. 439.

w

Water. Consumption of, by Locomotives, lis Cooling, by Forced Steam, 390. Feed, at Different Seasons, 12. Filling Tenders with, 431. High and Low Level. 69, 199. Rights Concerning, in Streams. 528. Scoop Operated by Air. 408. Spouts. Inconvenient, 304.

•Wear of Journals. 37.

•of Valves and Seats, Peculiar, 390.

Testing Tire, 273.

Tire, 297. Wedges. Oiling, 76.

•Prevent Cutting of. 109. Westinghouse Electric Brake and Heater. 374.

•Exhibits at Pan-American. 410.

•Friction Draft Gear. 20. •Wheel-barrow, Track, 326. Wheel Center. Davis. 50.

•Lathe, Driver for, 152. Wheels, Driving, in the Lathe. 234.

Notes on Truck, 62.

Prime Cause of Flat, 76.

•Ups and Downs of Driving. 367. ♦Whistles. Two Kinds of, 479. Wireless Telegraphy, 161. Women Railway Officials, 22. •Woodward & Powell Steel Rack. 312. •Wreck. Australian. 435.

•Disastrous. 241.

•Peru. 115. •Wright's Pedestal Spring Truck. 536.

X-Ray Inspection. 67.

•Yellowstone National Park I'limp. 47

A Practical Journal of Railway Motive Power and polling Stock

Vol. XIV

95 Liberty Street. New York, January. 1901.

No. I

Brooks Locomotive for Burlington, Cedar Rapids & Northern Railroad.

The annexed engraving illustrates a very handsome engine which the Brooks Locomotive Works call the "Chautauqua" type, built for the Burlington, Cedar Rapids & Northern for their heavy fast passenger service.

We think that this type of engine is destined to become very popular for the service for which this one was built, be- cause it enables the designers to put in a

Among the principal dimensions are; The weight on the driving wheels is 88,000 pounds, and 35,600 pounds on the engine truck. The boiler is the Player-Belpaire type, and the working pressure 210 pounds to the square inch. The firebox is 90J4 inches long by 74 inches wide. There are 306 tubes. The firebo.x provides 155.8 square feet of heating surface and the tubes 2,396 square feet, making a total of 2,551.8 square feet. The grate area is 45.32 square feet.

uniform mileage book; limiting sleeping- car charges to 35 cents per 100 miles for seat accommodations, and to 50 cents for a single berth and $1 for a double berth for each 100 miles; also prohibiting lower- ing the upper berth unless for actual use ; requiring the employment of a certain number of brakemen on all freight and passenger trains; permitting the railways to appoint special police ; creating the office of railroad commissioner; creating the office of State boiler inspector, particu-

TYPF. OF LOCO.MOTIVK.

very large firebox, and to make it deep enough so that it can be fired with suffi- cient depth of combustible to ensure a high firebox temperature. Looking at the engine in the photograph and line engrav- ings, it seems to be uncertain how the firebox rests upon the frames, but it is held up by expansion plates attached to the throat sheet and back head of the fire- box and securely bolted at the bottom to properly designed steel castings, which also form frame cross braces and foot- plate, respectively.

The engine has cylinders igj^ inches diameter by 26-inch stroke, and the driv- ing wheel is 75 inches diameter. The steam ports are 22 inches long by i^ inches.

Indiana Politicians "Agin" the Rail- roads.

The politicians of Indiana seldom fail to have a fling at railroads when oppor- tunity offers, even though their State has received more benefit from railroads than any other State in the Union. There is unusual activity among the politicians of that State at present in working up schemes to fleece railroad companies. A recent issue of the Railway Age says:

"The Indiana Legislature next month will not be devoid of interest to the rail- ways. Among the bills, new and old, which are expected to appear are these : Fixing a uniform rate of two cents a mile on all railways in the State; prescribing a

larlj- to inspect locomotive boilers, etc. The two-cent mileage bill passed the House at the last session, but was lost in the Senate ; the reduction of sleeping-car rates has been a favorite theme in that and many other States. Indiana is one of the twelve States which do not maintain a Railroad Commission, but it is also one of the States which seem to have least need for such a body, because having little to complain of against the railways. Having lived so peaceably with their 6,500 miles of lines, reaching every corner of the State and furnishing active competition, the peo- ple of Indiana may well ask why they should incur the expense of maintaining another bureau."

LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING

January, 19

A Hydro-Carbon Fire Kindter.

The kindling of locomotive fires is quite a problem in most roundhouses where the wcodpile and the oily-waste method still hold sway, but modern railroading de- mands a better and a quicker method. Of course, oil kindling is not new, but the de- tails of the Ferguson machine, which has been put on the market by Simpson & Andrews, Old Colony Building, Chicago, are believed to be new and novel.

It consists of a tank on wheels, a hose coupling for connection to the compressed- air system of the roundhouse, or to the main reservoir of engine, a hose carrying the spraying nozzle and a valve for con- trolling the oil and a'r. The tank holds 25 gallons, enough to kindle forty fires, as an average. The valve mixes the air and oil as is found best in each case. It takes from twenty-five to forty-five minutes to kindle a fire so as to get up steam enough to move the engine — the shorter time for

Educational Training for Railroad Service.

BY JOHN H. GOODYEAR.

From what has been said regarding technical or higher education and its con- nection with railroad service, it would ap- pear an idea is abroad that men with a technical or higher education have not only a good field in railroad service, but are in demand.

While it is true there is a limited field for technically educated men in the engin- eering department and occasional oppor- tunities in the mechanical department, pro- vided one is willing to serve a probational term of more or less duration, there would not seem to be a field, much less a demand, in any other branch of railroad service. There is, of course, a field in the sense that employers of labor will — other things being equal — naturally when hiring men. give those best equipped in the way of education the preference.

is nothing more or less than a commercial concern trading in transportation and em- ploying labor according to its mileage and amount of business handled. This labor, while it can hardly be called unskilled, is in its initial stage far from skilled labor. It is in fact intelligent unskilled labor which acquires skill as it passes through the various branches of the business and this would certainly appear the only prac- tical means of training men for railroad service.

As an illustration we would not, how- ever highly educated they might be, think of employing as engineers or conductors men who had not had experience in rail- road service. At the same time the neces- sary, experience may be and is acquired by intelligent unskilled men starting in as firemen and brakemen, respectively.

In railroad work subordination to rout- ine and method and an unreasoning com- pliance with rules or orders are the in-

ELEVATION OF BROOKS CHAUTAUQUA ENGINE.

a warm engine, the latter for a cold one. A piece of oily waste is lighted and thrown into the ashpan to start the flame, and then the nozzle of lighter is inserted and oil turned on. The flame passes up through coal till it ignites thoroughly. The firebox door is kept closed to prevent cold air !rtriking flue sheets, and it also aids draft. As it can be connected to main reservoir of engine, it does not require a compressed- air plant, and it can also be used for heat- ing tires, straightening bent frames or other work if desired.

The St. Louis Railway Club people have issued a list of fifty-three questions con- cerning important railroad matters for members to answer or study. The ques- tions have been compiled by a committee which have done their work very efii- ciently. Some of the questions cannot be answered except by vague guessing, but most of them are highly practical and con- stitute a good incentive to study.

In this connection, however, when ap- plied to technically educated men and their connection with railroad service generally, it is well to consider their future pros- pects. Apart from the few available posi- tions in the engineering and mechanical departments, there is practically very little in a railroad career to warrant men with the opportunity and means of acquiring higher education, devoting their time and money to acquiring what is — after all is said and done — but a theoretical knowl- edge of railroading the application of which would, for the majority of them, mean several years of hard work, moder- ate wages and discontent with their lot.

In our desire to increase the standard of efficiency of railroad employes, we should not allow the question of higher education to run away with us. To talk of the edu- cation of railroad men is, to quote Mr. C. E. Perkins, like talking about the educa- tion of dry-goods merchants. As a mat- ter of fact, a railroad — in the abstract —

dispensable conditions of service, and it would appear that higher education is not conducive to these requisites of ser- vice.

Railroad labor is, to a very great extent, composed of fairly intelligent men who in youth either did not have the inclination, opportunity or means to acquire a trade or higher education. This class exists in every country and invariably drifts and anchors in railroad and kindred service.

Regarding railroad officials, it will be found that, apart fromthe engineers (main- tenance of way), most of the eminent rail- road men have come up from the ranks. There are exceptions, being men who by influence or the fact that they have shown aptitude for some particular branch of the business, have secured good positions without working up through the ranks.

Quite recently Sir C. R. Wilson, presi- dent of the Grand Trunk system, refer- ring to the question of a successor to Charles M. Hays, general manager, is re-

January, igoi.

LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING

ported to have said : "We consider Amer- ica far ahead of any other country in the management and building of railroads, and England and the other countries over the water can learn considerable to their ad- vantage from them."

While this praise — coming from such a Source — is very gratifying, we know it is true that America leads the world in rail- road building and management, and the credit for this condition of affairs is to a great extent due to those eminent railroad men who have come up from the ranks.

One hesitates to say what one thinks in regard to this matter, for fear it might be construed as an attempt to belittle higher education. It would, however, appear to the writer that the entrance into railroad service — with the exception of the cases quoted — of men with higher education is not a practical solution of the question of increa-ing the standard of efficiency of railroad employes. This for the reason that such men would not take kindly to the hardship of railroad work, with its few prizes in the way of higher positions.

For several years quite a number of prominent railroads have been solving the question by the following means :

(1) Hiring none but men physically and morally fit, intelligent, fairly well edu- cated and not over a certain age.

(2) Furnishing facilities — in the way of instruction cars, etc. — whereby men can, on the line of their road (each road hav- ing peculiarities, etc., of its own) receive practical instruction in regard to their work.

(3) Establishment of relief and pension funds, etc., thereby inducing men to re- main in the service of one company during their railroad life.

(4) Promoting men from the ranks to official positions, and not hiring outsiders for responsible positions while there are men eligible for the position in the ser- vice.

In conclusion would say, apparently the field for men with higher education lies in government service, and possibly in the work pertaining to the construction of, building up and handling the American merchant marine service — a service badly

needed.

About Bearings — Hot and Cool.

When jumping at conclusions — and we all do it at times — we are much too apt to overlook the parts that are attending strictly to business and only see those that are giving trouble. The breaking of eccen- tric straps on some engines which have extra large valves and long travel is a case in mind. Leaving aside the question of reducing either the size or travel of the valve, we find the trouble confined to one or two straps, instead of being an epi- demic. The first conclusion is that there is something wrong with the design or the material, and bronze is often substituted for cast iron in such cases.

The fact that some of the straps — prob- ably three out of the four — are running

cool and giving no trouble, is too often overlooked, and we only see the defects of the one. If but one strap runs cool, it shows that it is possible to make them so as to give satisfaction, and that something is wrong with the ones which give trouble. It may be either the material or the work- manship, and the fact that one runs as it should proves this to be the case.

in the weight or travel of valve.

Another instance of a similar nature may help to illustrate the point more forcibly. An engine of the Atlantic type had trouble with one of the bo.xes on the trailing wheels, while the box on the other side ran perfectly cool. Investigation showed that the inside end of the box was comparatively cool and that the heat in-

CROSS-SECTIOX OF "cH.\UT.\UQUA" FIREBOX.

It is of course possible to reduce the work of eccentric and straps by reducing the travel of the valve or its size (and consequently its weight), or both, and it would probably be advantageous to do this in some cases. But as long as one eccen- tric and strap remain cool and work with- out difficulty, the fault is not necessarily

creased toward the wheel. A new box acted in the same manner, and a different metal was considered. The fact that the other box was running cool was over- looked, and also that the heat was not evenly distributed.

Careful consideration shows that the box was unevenl)' loaded, so as to bear heavily

LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING

January, 1901.

against the hub of the trailer, and that if this was remedied there would be no need to look further for a new bearing metal. There is a cause for every effect, and it is better, where possible, to remove the cause than to remedy it in other ways. When similar bearings act in an entirely different manner, it is generally better to find why the one fails than to devise ways and means for entirely changing the condi- tions. This brings about new problems which may be avoided by carefully study- ing present conditions.

The Railway Mechanical Conventions.

The joint committee of the Master Car Builders' and of the Railway Master Me- chanics' Association met at the Hotel Iro- quois at Buffalo, on December nth, to de-

ventions held at the same place in June last, which were : Single room, one per- son, without bath, $3 ; double room, one person, without bath, $4; ordinary double room, one person, with bath, $5 ; extra large double room, one person, with bath, $6; double room, two persons, without bath, each persons, $3 ; ordinary double room, two persons, with bath, each person, $4 ; extra large double room, two persons, with bath, each person, $5. Applications for rooms, etc., should be made to Woolley & Gerrans, the proprietors of the Grand Union Hotel at Saratoga Springs, or at the Iroquois Hotel, Buffalo.

Some desire was manifested to hold the convention at some other place than Saratoga, but nobody was present who could guarantee that the necessary accom-

sisted that the arrangement led to hurry- ing through the business at a rapid rate, which was not conducive to the best inter- ests of either association. It was then agreed to return to the old practice of holding the conventions in different weeks. A novel change was agreed to, which was that the Master Mechanics should meet first and the Master Car Builders in the following week. As now agreed upon, the Master Mechanics will meet on the third Wednesday of June and the Master Car Builders on the following Monday.

The large United States annex at Vin- cennes (Paris E.xposition), together with its steam and electrical equipment, has been sold by Messrs. Charles Neat & Co., 112 Queen Victoria street, E. C, London,

ally lor Locomotive Engineering, by F. W. Blauvell.

EXPERIMENT.\L ELECTRIC ELEVATED TR.\IN — NO 0FFICI.\L D.\T.'\ .W.-ML.^BLE,

cide on the next place for holding the annual conventions. There were present on behalf of the Master Car Builders' As- sociation Messrs. J. T. Chamberlain, J. J. Hennessey, E. D. Bronner, J, H. McCon- nell and S. P. Bush. On behalf of the Master Mechanics' Association there were W. S. Morris, A. M. Waitt, Geo. W. West and Angus Sinclair.

A sub-committee which had been pre- viously appointed to inquire into the facili- ties offered at different places for the ac- commodation of the conventions reported in favor of Saratoga, and it was agreed to hnld the annual convention at that place with headquarters at the Grand Union Hotel.

The arrangement as to rates, etc., are the same as those that governed the con-

modation could be provided elsewhere. The machinery and railway supply exhibi- tion which has become such an important feature of these conventions now rule out some places that might be able to furnish the hotel accommodation. Niagara Falls made a bid for the conventions, but it was very evident that even the hotel accom- modation was too limited. A representa- tive of the hotel proprietors of Atlantic City attended the meeting, but he could guarantee nothing, and so Atlantic City was dropped, although a good many mem- bers would like to dwell for a week by the salt sea waves.

A discussion arose about the desirability of holding both conventions in one week, as was done last year, and a member of the Master Car Builders' committee in-

acting on behalf of the American authori- ties, to a Manchester engineering firm. This building, which was constructed by the Berlin Iron Company, of Berlin, Conn., measures about 350 feet in length by 126 feet wide. The power plant consists of two 250 horse-power steam boilers and a "Ball" engine of 300 horse-power coupled to a 2So-kilowatt generator. There is an electric traveling crane of 30-ton capacity, running the whole length of the main aisle. The building and its plant are now being taken to Mancliester to be re-erected there. — Engineering.

It is reported that two regular lines of steamers are to begin running from New Orleans to Europe in connection with the Illinois Central.

January, igoi.

LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING

Bits of Railroad History— Being Ex- tracts From the Diary of my Great-Grandfather.

BV R. E. MARKS.

My great grandfather on my mother's side was rather peculiar in some ways — apt to be "sot" in his ideas — but had withal very good judgment on current events, and his estimates of men and their inventions were fairly correct — more so than the average. Moreover, he was an Englishman by birth, and was fortunate enough to have enough money to indulge his fancies, travel when he liked and enjoy life generally. But alas ! the money has not descended to this day and generation — only a "find," in the shape of a diary or journal which the old gentleman kept more religiously than he ever did anything else.

It differed from the usual form of diary, which gives the date, weather and a few other dry and musty facts which nobody cares a rap about, and is only written to

was withdrawn. Of course the "Rocket" is all right, and George Stephenson de- serves credit, although they do say he gets much that belongs to others.

I have always had a soft spot in my heart for Richard Trevithick. the father of them all in practical moving engines. Other men tried, or told someone else how to try, but Trevithick did. That French- man Cugnot, 'way back in 1769, did pretty well on a road wagon ; but our Dicky made it a success in 1803. Smooth rails and wheels (45-inch wheels), a boiler 51 inches by 6 feet long and a cylinder like a gun barrel, 8J4 x 54 inches — not a beauty, but it went. If I'd been old enough to realize things as long ago as that, I believe I'd have helped him along — with funds, of course ; he had the brains.

In the meantime that Yankee, Oliver Evans, has been at work, and came pretty near beating our Trevithick, for in 1804 he built his machine with an awful name

it as a base, but he ripped it up so no one would have known it. He had ideas on boilers, and he put in a lot of tubes in place of the one large one. Then he used a fan for blowing the fire.

1S30-

I went to America in the fall. Wanted to see how things were going in the place, and I found they hadn't been idle in rail- roading. Stephenson's "America" and Foster & Rastruck's "Stourbridge Lion" arrived lart year, and Horatio Allen made a try with the latter, but it seems to me he failed to show the usual Yankee grit, for he gave it up after a few trials. Said 'twas too high and too heavy.

Peter Cooper had more determination, and though a merchant, he made the the first American engine that would go. I'd rather have seen the "Tom Thumb" on the Baltimore & Ohio than the Rainhill trials — but I didn't, worse luck.

fill up anyhow. His was different — but you shall judge of that later.

Some of the old gentleman's effects were recently sent to me, after lying in garrets and cellars for years, and things by the way, which no one else seemed to want (that's why I got 'em), and among them I fished out the aforesaid journal. It dates away back to 1800, and I omit a lot not relevant to railroading; but he must have been mechanically inclined. If he ap- pears egotistical at times, don't blame me — that's a trait of the family that ran out before my time. Well, here goes :

i82g— Well, the Rainhill trials are over, and Stephenson's "Rocket" carried off the £500 prize, but I- — and lots of others — think the "Novelty," built by Braithwate and Erics- son, the better engine. It is a trim little machine and ran steady and fast, but, un- fortunately, several leaks developed and it

("Orukter Amphibolo"), which not only runs itself on land, but takes to water like a duck. He gave us the high-pressure idea and seemed to be a bright chap, but he met with the same fate as Trevithick — they called him a lunatic, and he couldn't earn enough to buy bread — let alone but- ter.

The idea took a good long nap, until Bleikinsfp, in 181 1, and Hedley, in 1813, took a hand with his "Puffing Billy," and hauled ten coal wagons five miles an hour with 50 pounds of steam. He found that it was too severe on the track, and so doubled the number of wheels, making it the first eight-wheel engine.

Over in France. Marc Seguin was en- gineering the first road there, the St. Etienne & Lyons, in 1826. I was over there that year, and Seguin showed me his new machine before it was finished. He bought an old Stephenson engine and used

There's a fellow in Baltimore. Ross Winans, that I'm watching pretty close ; seems a good deal like I think Dicky Trevithick must have been. He's always doing something. He has made anti-fric- tion bearings, put them outside of tlie frame and uses coned wheels. Why didn't I think of that before?

l?3i—

This Baltimore & Ohio road is one of the best examples of Yankee daring I know of. They are spending money like water and pushing it as fast as they can into a wilderness. Some of the rails are laid on granite, the stone and grading alone costing over $46,000 a mile.

They are offering prizes for the best en- gines, and good ones they are, too — $4,000 for the first, and $3,500 for the next best.

A country watchmaker. Phineas Davis, builds a four-wheel coupled engine with a tubular boiler. He calls it the "York,"

LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING

January, 1901.

after hi? native town, and he wins the prize. Davis also goes to work for the road, and i • associated with Ross Winans, whom I've mentioned before, and they make a good team. The "York" weighs only 31,2 tons, yet it pulls 14 tons as high as 14 miles an hour.

Other engines are being built, and it seems as though everyone had gone daft on locomotives. The West Point Foundry built a locomotive last year — the "Best Friend" — and have just turned out an- other, the "West Point," designed by Allen, for the South Carolina road. The "Best Friend" is hardly true to its name, when the fireman is in question, for when that dusky individual got impatient and

humiliated and wanted to jump out and go home — but I didn't, for we soon reached a speed of 25 miles an hour. I held my breath — what a glorious way to travel ! I soon came back to earth, however; for the engine burned pine fuel, and great clouds of smoke pour back over us, till my opposite has some of her beauty hidden by the soot. Cinders and sparks come back, too, and here was a chance to re- deem m3'self, for as they fell in her lap. I picked them off and threw them out — burned my fingers, of course; but they were healed by smiles and sympathy. But it is an odd scene — umbrellas are raised, but only to add fuel to be devoured, rather than prove a protection, and it i-^ amusing

Wales, but never before on a locomotive. It has drivers 5 feet in diameter, and also runs on the Mohawk & Hudson, where it has made a mile a minute — so they say. 1832— Home again, and I find that England has not been idle either. Stephenson has earned the reputation of skillfully adapting the plans of others, but of doing no im- proving himself. In other words, he i? not an inventor, but a successful builder. There's a difference between the two. and each has his place. Timothy Hackworth, on the other hand, is original, and being a good builder besides, is ahead of George with his "Globe" and "Middlesboro." The latter is a six-coupled engine, the first we

Jmeoinvtiue Enj/ineeri

DETAILS OF HIGHLAND RAILWAY TEN-WHEELER.

tied down the safety valve, it promptly blew up, and his friends saw him no more.

I must not overlook my invitation to the opening of the Mohawk & Hudson road on August 9th of this year (1831). The West Point Foundry have built the "De Witt Clinton." an engine with 55-2 x l6-inch cylinders, four wheels, all drivers. with wrought-iron tires, and weighing 3'^ tons. There were numerous guests, many of them representing the first families, and we were all anxious for the start. The seats in the cars faced each other, and when the engine took up the slack to start (for the chains had at least 2 feet slack), I promptly landed in the lap of a very de- mure damsel opposite. Of course I rode backwards.

She took the sudden onslaught as gra- ciously as possible, but I was deeply

to see portly and staid . old aristocrats vigorously slapping out the fire on a seat- mate's clothes. Finally we stopped, and as the cars ran together, the occupants of the rear seats returned the compliment of the start, and for one brief moment the daughter of the Lieutenant Governor (as I was told) clutched wildly at my coat — but we :■ topped too quickly to suit me.

The Camden & Amboy road has im- ported a Stephenson engine, the "John Bull," which weighs 10 tons and is the heaviest in the country.

Still in .•\merica; but this year (1831) is so full of new things here that I can't bear to leave. John B. Jervis has had the "Experiment" built at West Point, and it is believed to be the first engine with a "bogie'' truck. True, these were used on cars in the old davs at Merthyr Tvdvil, in

know of. James Kennedy has designed the famous "Bury," with its round top.

The Glasgow & Garnkirk road has been opened in Scotland, and Stephenson ran the first engine over it — named for him- self. Mails are being carried by train and progress seems assured.

Baldwin, of Philadelphia, has started in also, but I'm sorry his "Ironsides" fol- lows Stephenson's designs so closely. Most of the Yankees build them different, just to be different — but Baldwin is evidently a conservative chap.

Stephenson is building all his engines alike as far as possible, until he has to change to meet Hackworth and others. He isn't a leader, but he makes more money than the others. 1836-

Once more I'm in .A.merica, and I find

January, 1901.

LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING

things much improved. Baldwin no longer follows Stephenson — in fact, he struck out for himself in his second engine. He's a good business man, too, which too many of them are not.

There are not so many freaks as there were a few years ago. This locomotive craze, if I can call it so, has brought out many bright men in both countries. Here in America there are the Xorris Brothers, Long, Stevens, Garrett, Eastwick, Harri- son and a lot of others; nor must we for- get James, who, though most of his efforts have been in road wagons, has developed a number of improvements. William Mor- ris has just brought out liis "Washing- ton." and the work it did during the trial at Peters Island, where it drew a load of 19,200 pounds up a rise of i in 14 at the rate of 15 miles an hour, is very creditable. The incline is 2,800 feet long. If the original Washington was as strong in pro- portion, it's no wonder the colonists won their fight. This "Washington" is a good- looking machine, too — a pair of 4-foot drivers just ahead of the firebox and a four-wheel truck ahead, cylinders outside, and a Bury boiler.

Henry R. Campbell, of Philadelphia, has an engine built by a James Brooks, of same city, with four driving wheels and four carrying wheels ahead. I rather like the plan. It looks well and seems sensible from every point of view.

The Cumberland Valley road has put on night cars, and out of curiosity I took a trip in one of them. They are a novelty, that's sure; but unless I absolutely have to travel at night, hereafter I don't use them.

'Twas a cold night, and the bedclothes were a minus quantity. There were a pil- low that almost got lost in one ear, and a mattress that would have fitted the other if it hadn't been on top. They told me there were chilled wheels under the car, and I know the cars were. I had a cold for a month, but I also had the experience.

1837- Things are devel.iping so rapidly here I don't want to leave the country. Garrett. Eastwick and Horrison are making quite a stir with the "Hercules." This has •wheels like the Campbell, and young Har- rison has planned a set of levers between the drivers on each side to equalize the ■\\ eight. They are the best invention for many a day. This isn't the only good thing either. It's a good-sized engine, too, 12 X 18-inch cylinders. There's another queer arrangement, too — between the valve and valve seat is a plate which is moved either front or back and reverses the en- gine by admitting steam to either end of cylinder desired.

Letters from home tell me that freaks have been rampant there. A Tom Harri- son, whoever he is, has built two engines for the Great Western road which ought to land the man who designed them in a

madhouse. His first fool trick is to put the boiler on one truck and the engine on another in both cases. The 'Hurricane"— one of the pair — has lo-foot drivers, while the others are only 6 feet, but geared 3 to I, so as to equal 18 feet; the cylinders are 16 to 20. Harrison seemed to think wheels make them go — but there's no use wasting time, ink and paper telling what an idiot a man of this kind is.

Venerable Engineer Pensioned.

The following letters received in this office explain themselves :

Thinking it may be of interest to you, I enclose copy of letter received from Mr. Freeman Borst, who was pensioned in November. He has been railroading since 1852 and running an engine on the district

wide by 170 feet long, two stories and basement, and built on the usual machine- shop gallery style of construction. A traveling crane, 30 feet wide, runs the full length of the building, leaving galleries on the second floor, on both sides, 30 feet wide. The construction is steel through- out and designed to safely carry a load of 300 pounds per square foot. This building was erected for the purpose of taking care of three important departments of the company, viz. : iron valve, injector and safety valve. It is a model machine shop and is equipped throughout with the very latest tools and appliances. The steam plant consists of a 125 horse-power special Babcock & Wilcox boiler, built for a safe working pressure of 400 pounds per square inch. In connection with this boiler there

CROSS-SECTIOX OF HIGHL.^ND R.\ILW.\V TEX-WHEELER.

between Cumberland and Grafton since 1857.

Mr. Borst wears a forty-five years' ser- vice medal.

The switch key he turned in had been carried by him more than eighteen years.

Jos. BlLLIXGH.\M,

Div. Master Mechanic. Cumberland, Md.

Keyser. W. V.\.. Xov. 21, 1900. Mr. Jos. Billingham,

Div. Master Mechanic. On account of being pensioned a few days ago. which relieves me from duty for the remainder of my days. I enclose you my switch key with many thanks, and pray the party who may become possessor of it may have as good luck as I have had and reap the same reward.

Freem.\n Borst, Late Engineman 3d Div. B. & O. Keyser, W. Va.

are a number of appliances for testing all goods under steam, air and hydraulic pres- sure. The building is lighted by electricity and the power is furnished by a 100 horse- power engine. The exterior of the build- ing pre-ents a very handsome appearance, being pressed brick throughout. The erec- tion of this building will not in any way reduce the building now occupied by the company on East Eighth street, Cincinnati, which will hereafter be entirely devoted to brass work. This new building in- creases the manufacturing facilities about 25 per cent, and gives employment to 100 men in addition to the force already oper- ated, bringing the total force up to 500 hands. The opening was celebrated by a reception and dance, which was attended by a thousand people.

The Lunkenheimer Company have just completed a new machine shop, 90 feet

On New Zealand railroads women are employed as gate-keepers at level cross- ings. The standard pay for this work is $5 a month. Yet New Zealand is reputed to be the paradise of highly paid labor. Perhaps the sex makes the difference.

LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING

January, 1901.

Heating the Roundhouse of the Chi- cago & Northwestern Ry. Co. at Clinton, Iowa.

The method of heating adopted in the new roundhouse of the Chicago & North- western Railway at Clinton, Iowa — proba- bly the largest in the world — presents an interesting study. The house is 375 feet in outside diameter, the interior circle be- ing 212 feet in diameter. The inside clear- ance between walls is 81 feet 6 inches, and

length of time during which a locomotive must remain out of service.

As most effectually combining the ad- vantages required to meet these conditions the Blower System of combined heating and ventilation was selected and installed in accordance with the plans of the B. F. Sturtevant Company, of Boston, Mass.

Located outside of the house and filling the space between it and the nearby ma- chine shop and storeroom, is the Sturte-

sections in three groups and enclosed in a steel-plate casing, rendering the appara- tus at once fireproof and directing the cur- rent of air to the fan under whose action it moves.

Passing upward from the fan the air enters a large horizontal galvanized iron duct which extends to a position midway between the inner and outer circumfer- ences of the roundhouse and there branches into separate pipes extending in

PI..\N FOR HEATING ROUNDHOUSE.

provision is made for 48 stalls, or, includ- ing entrance and exit, 50. As the length of the longest locomotive is 62 feet 8J/2 inches ample space is thus left around it. In selecting the system of heating, the desirability was recognized of combining both the means of maintaining proper temperature in the building and of rapidly melting snow and ice from the locomotives during the winter season. Upon the rap- idity with which the latter process can be accomplished must of course depend the

vant apparatus, consisting of a steel plate fan wheel 12 feet in diameter enclosed in a steel-plate housing with upward dis- charge. To the fan shaft a llH x 16 hori- zontal Sturtevant engine is directly con- nected. This arrangement makes it pos- sible to operate the fan at any desired speed and with entire independence of any other source of motive power. The air is, by means of the fan, drawn through a heater having a capacity of 20.000 lineal feet of one-inch pipe built of Sturtevant

either direction entirely around the house until they meet at the opposite end of the same diameter. Being carried overhead they in nowise encroach upon valuable space.

Distribution of air is secured through branching pipes which are led downward along the sides of the vertical posts and branch beneath the ground level so as to connect with the pipes extending to the pits upon either side. The vertical pipes, fitting close to the posts as they do, are

January, 1901.

LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING

protected from injury and do not occupy effective floor space. Just above the floor line each is provided with a slide damper by means of which heated air may be admitted to the building. There being over fifty of these branch pipes with these open- ings, it is evident that the circulation of air is all that can be desired.

Each branch pipe to a pit is provided with a damper operated from floor level so that air may be locally discharged in large volumes. The result is that an ex- cessive amount of hot air is delivered to the pit , and rises evenly across the run- ning gear of the locomotives. The high temperature rapidly melts the snow and ice while the air, with the greediness due to high temperature, rapidly absorbs all moisture and carries it away. .A. hot, dry condition is therefore assured, and the time during which a locomotive must be kept out of service is usually reduced by fully two-thirds, a most important feature in locomotive practice. It is evident that the large volume of air admitted plays an important part in the process of ventilat- ing. Individual roof ventilators are pro- vided for every other stall, thus insuring positive upward movement of air from floor level and its escape when its duty is completed.

One of the most essential advantages of this method of heating lies in the fact that the entire heating surface (far less than would be required for direct heating) is massed in a firepoof casing in the adjoin- ing building. The volume and tempera- ture of the air is immediately under the control of a single individual, while local requirements can be met by the adjustment of dampers as shown and described. The exhaust steam from the fan engine is utilized in the heater, so that the cost of operating the fan is reduced to practic- ally nothing. Live steam is supplied to the remainder of the heater. It is, however, customary in ordinary mill practice where there is ample quantity of exhaust steam to utilize it in the heater as can always be readily done without producing back pressure on the main engine.

Tim Mackey's New Year.

BY R. E. MARKS.

Railroad men are not much given to romancing as a rule, although you now and then find a fellow who talks to his engine as though it was a thing of life instead of a mass of iron and steel; but these fellows don't run in the pool. That takes the romance out of it, and iron be- comes iron and his engine love turns into a "battleship" or a "hog," according to the road he is on.

Tim Mackey wasn't any exception to the rule — no romance about him — and yet way down in his heart he was as full of chivalry as any knight errant — and more than some. His coat of mail was only a pair of overalls and his helmet removable only by a liberal application of soap and water.

but his chivalry reached clear down to his pocket-book — deeper than it often goes.

Tim isn't a young man — was once, I suppose, but that was before I knew him — fact is, he must be sixty, I should imagine, and he has been hostler in the Northamp- ton yard for years. Ran an engine on the northern division years ago, they tell me — till his wife died and left him the two boys to bring up.

Then he gave up the road and got a job as hostler so as to be near home. Wanted to keep an eye on those boys all he could lor he knew they'd be wild, I guess — probably was himself once. But he paid the penalty when it came to watching these boys, they tell me.

He had a little cottage near the round- house and he hired a middle-aged woman to keep house and look after the boys — but she couldn't do that, nor Tim either for that matter. Did the best she could.

train 51 and went under — no one knows how. Tim didn't say much or do much, wasn't like him, but he saw that Mrs. Jack and the baby were comfortable and went back to work.

'Twasn't long before Tim had a call from an insurance man.

"Is this Mr. Mackey?"

"That's me name, sor."

"Mr. Mackey, I have a check for you. Your son John was insured in our com- pany for a thousand dollars in your name.''

"Dcn't want it, sor, and I won't take it nayther. Why can't you pay it to his wife — b'lcngs to her, not me."

"But ts in your name, Mr. Macke)- — probably taken out before he was married. Can't give it to anyone but you. But if you want her to have it — and it's mighty generous of you, Mr. Mackey — why just come with me and we'll fix it."

BLU\\ ER USED IN HEATING ROUNDHOUSE.

though, and Tim was grateful for that, even if she was a terror to get along with. Made life miserable for him sometimes, but he didn't kick as long as the boys were cared for.

Jimmy, the oldest boy, ran away young, and where or what he is. no one around here knows — but it's the hope of seeing him again that keeps Tim up and work- ing— he'd collapse if 'twasn't for that, they all tell me.

Jack, the younger, went wild, too, and lit out early, but his father kept track of him and when he married about three years ago, Tim began to look younger. Then when little Tim appeared on the scene old Tim was almost happy. Used to run down to Ware every little while to have a romp and see the folks; always liked Jack's wife, he did, and helped him get started housekeeping.

Then came that young blizzard in '98 and the next he knew Jack had been brought home dead. Fell or slipped from

"Didn't the by pay for it? Why isn't it the woman's and the little uns? 'Taint mine, and I don't want it."

So ihey went to Ware and with little delay had the thousand dollars in the bank to the credit of Mrs. Jack, who was tearfully grateful and whose opinion of fathers-in-law had taken another boost— and no wonder.

In the meantime there has been another quiet little drama played. Tim hadn't lived in the cottage for two years, but had boarded. Only a few knew the rea- son. He couldn't get along with old Miss Barstow any longer. Worried him to death, he told a few of his cronies. But as she hadn't any home he wouldn't turn her out, and so went out himself and boarded. Gave her the use of the house, and I am told often carried a basket of wood or a bag of coal to the door be- tween dark and daylight.

Old Miss Barstow died last montii, though, and so Tim had the place fixed

LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING

January, 1901.

a c

>

.3

3 S 8

0 C

>>

>

u bo

c bo

c

ni

a. a.

£

a.

cS

3

a. g

c ■£ 0 ■"

'■" 2

3 50

•S .5

s'i

V >,

a. j2

c 3

0

5) •0

0

0

bb _c

>

"5

•0

3

•0

•a c

0

C .0

3

0

3 0

"^

C

'B.

s

a

0 i- 0.

3

E

•0

%

0

0 c

"3

0

S

0 3

u

S

oT

cr

>

J«

OJ

g

(/I

3

0

_^_,

5

u

_o

0

j:

0

>>

C

p

"rt

«

1

•0

^

>2

1-. 3

0

0

bo

j:

3

;S

"2

J2

n

)-•

0

'S

3

.s

rt

E

t

1

3

-^

3

c

C3

rt

S

0

rt

>

S"

X)

c

rt

.2

&

«J

cr

s

^

0

_o

3

^

bo

^

M

3

C

c

c

5

15

C

1*

u=

s

'S, 0

3

1

.M

o<

0

3 g

C

0.

"5

3

3

'-^

c]

3

J3

rt

-o

—

3

0

J3

~

J2

M

E -S-b S

M 3 -a

g • _& -a ^

o « -3 0 I

C ~ Dh '^ 2

« *' *J >> _

Etn — 3

U g ^ .2

i (_) 5 rt

<« cr 3 •-

5 -<■ -- S-

•S ~ 2

IS bo S

S 3 >, y

^ •■= m „

£ Ji= S

S ii ■■ E

tl '^ rt D

ho ^

60 "a!

3 >

, boH

3 jf 'I

(U < _

J= _ 3

, ^. ^' 1 i ^K

''i £^

I > i>H

■,■5 ./I 3

E S E

E-S

o

II

3-5 ci "rt S

S 2 -

o 2 ■- H bo

5 vo i^j=;

•5 S"^ c — - ■"So

^o ^^ *"

Sag Q 8 Z I ".I

t; bo -o 3

u 3 3 t;

MH m 1; c(

H -g W

I P .£ g •«

si 1 ^ •« =

;; rt «J o I

<u ^ Ji *" J.

0

0

V

%

>

0 V

bo

3

3

3

3 >

0 >>

t

'S

a.

_6

3 .1

"i «

12 ^

« 5

ho

3

3 0

bi)

1

•0

3 cu

S

bo

3

E

i 0

3

>> H

0 •a

3

«

>

rt

0

0

•0

E

0 bo

•5

c

E

e 0

3 0

e

"0

3

C

Ji 3

i 1

>

_u

.E

H

•a

n)

.-

E

rt

3 <

j=

B

;-

1^

H

.ti

m

3

bo

0.

V

ho

_3 1

m >

>>

H

E

0

•0

3

bi)

3

■y.

>

0. 0 C

V

3

bo 3

e

2 «

03

> 0

0 s

•0 rt 0

>s

u

u

rt

>H

J:

^.

■£

■B

^

E ^ =

January, IQOI.

LO((»:\I(»TIVK KXCIIXEEKING

General Correspondence.

All tetters for nils aepiirliiu-iit iiiiisl };ive name of autlio

FLOODS ON ENGLISH ROAIl;

Floods on an English Railway.

Tlie photograph- from which the an- nexed illustrations were taken were sent to us by Mr. Wilson Worsdell, locomotive superintendent of the North Eastern Railway of England, who writes :

"B;ing a subscriber to your paper, and noticing that on several occasions you have very interesting views of railway occurrences, etc.. I think the enclosed photographs will be of interest to your readers. On Friday night, October 26th, we had an unprecedented rainfall, about 3J4 inches in twelve hours, flooding sev- eral parts of this railway ; and at a place called CuUercoats, on one of our sea.ude branches, the station was completely flooded, and. owing to the ballast having been washed away, a passenger train was derailed, and the unique experience of having to take the passengers out of the railway cars by means of boats, as shown in the eiclosed photographs, had to be re- sorted to.

"I thought perhaps you might like to publish them in your journal, if you thought them of sufficient interest.

"W. Worsdell."

itorial staff had been keeping bad com- pany. Must the link motion go? Why, the idea is ridiculous, and to admit the dire possibility is like saying amen to a proposal to pull down the palladium of our liberties or to make confession that American locomotive designers and master mechanics are liable to make mistakes in their chosen business. Perish the thought! The link motion has been one of the most

cherished idols of the American locomo- tive. Have we not rejected with scorn every substitute offered to move the valves and reverse a locomotive, and have we not praised it and boasted of its mer- its so much that we ought to be wedded to its perfection for all time? .\nd now you, in the editorial page of Locomotive Engineering, the leading lo- comotive paper of the world, admit that our idol is not all gold.

I have admitted myself that it was no easy matter sometimes to scheme a link motion for certain ten-wheel engines that was without its faults; but I never had the temerity to propose a change from the link motion. I am aware that ^lason built many locomotives in which the slide valves were operated by what was called the Walschaert motion, and I am doubtful if any of them have remained out of the scrap heap to this day. I have seen loco- motives using Joy's motion which has no eccentrics, only an arrangement of rods and levers, and I am certain that they have all disappeared from this continent. Then I have seen divers other valve mo- tions, like the Wilson and the Strong and the Lewis and some others of that ilk. but when you ask where are those motions to- day, echo answers where ! Even the Cor- liss valve motion had its chance, and it kept the track men busy along the line picking up fragments of the gear which they carried home and converted into pokers and weapons of offense. Now,

Defence of the Link Motion.

On finishing the reading of an article on page 522 of Locomotive Engineering entitled "Must the Link Motion Go," I looked the paper over to see that I had not been reading any other paper, and then I made u|) my mind that one of your ed-

FLOODS ox ENGLISH RO.VDS

LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING

January, 1901.

since we have gone through the whole gamut o£ valve motions and gone back to the link, why should you come in to dis- turb our complacency and suggest de- serting our only safe stand-by? If you are really in earnest about wanting to abolish the link. I should like you to give an illustration of what you could offer as a substitute on a ten-wheel engine. Also I should like to know if you are prepared

On the nth of this month the crown sheet gave way in forward part of the box, pull- ing fifty-two stays through. The engineer claims to have had one gage of water and 130 pounds of steam when sheet let go. His reputation for truth and honesty is first class, and we have no reason to doubt his statement. He has been discharged for burning crown sheet. Now, will you please answer the following questions :

(4) If this crown sheet was really burned by this engineer, what will be the condition of sheets and stays, threads in sheets and on stays and seams where ex- posed, and where would effect of heating show most? Crown sheet had 3-inch crown and 3 inches higher in front.

I would be pleased if you could answer this by personal letter at once, as it may assist this man to hold his position and also keep his reputation clear as an engi- neer. You understand what it means to be discharged for burning an engine.

Hoping you will grant this favor, I am, Engineer.

[Whoever was in charge of this engine displayed criminal carelessness in not hav- ing the boiler thoroughly inspected after the firebox sheets were overheated. The fact that the staybolts were giving trouble by leaking after the overheating ought to have been taken as a warning that some- thing was wrong. It is a most reckless proceeding to increase to 160 pounds pres- sure a boiler that was designed to carry ■^nly 135 pounds. A hydraulic test of 180 pounds was not sufficient for a boiler carrying 160 pounds. — Ed.]

Effect of

Feed Water at Seasons.

Different

FLOODS ON ENGLISH RO.VDS.

All motive-power departments are per- haps at this season of the year taxed to their fullest capacity to cope with the de- mands of the transportation people and

to recommend a valve motion for a loco- motive that does not increase the valve lead when hooked back.

A. CONVETH.

Camden. X. I.

The Crown Sheet Failed.

I am a constant reader of your paper, and have been for some years, and con- sider it good authority on subjects pertain- ing to locomotive engines and boilers. I have a case before me upon which I would be pleased to have your opinion. A loco- motive boiler, which is seventeen years old and has been in constant service, was constructed to carry 135 pounds working pressure. The firebox was renewed seven years ago. the boiler continuing to carry same pressure; 15-16 crown stays, 4^ x 4'/2-inch centers. About twenty months ago the engine was fired up in roundhouse with low water crown sheet, and flue sheet and side sheets were heated to a cherry red down as low as the eighth row of flues. The boiler was filled up with cold water at once, not waiting for sheets to cool. The firebox had no work done on it in consequence of this heating, except to drive up heads of stays, so they would not leak. The crown stays have given con- siderable trouble from leaking ever since.

Eight months ago the engine boiler was given a hydraulic test of 180 pounds and working pressure raised to 160 pounds.

FLOUDS 0.\ ENGLISH RO.VDS

(1) Do you think this boiler was safe with the increased pressure of 160 pounds, an increase of 25 pounds?

(2) Was the test of 180 pounds hy- draulic pressure sufficient?

(3) What effect would this heating and sudden cooling of sheets and stays have on them as to their strength and durabil- ity?

to add to the embarrassment of being short of "power" they have to contend for a period of six or eight weeks with the disadvantage of leaky flues. There is apparently no cause for the flues to con- tribute to the embarrassment, as the fire- men exercise the most exacting care in the performance of their part without accom- plishing the desired result.

January, 1901.

LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING

13

The writer has observed for the past three or four years that the flues give the most annoyance during the fall rain- storms. Those conditions may be attrib- uted to the chemical substance leached from the decayed vegetable matter. This chemical element commingles with the sur- face water and is carried by the rills and streamlets into the storage supply, thence it is conducted into the tank of the loco- motive. This chemical substance seems to be very searching in its property, as is in- dicated by the condition of the fire-box. There would seem to be some evidence to substantiate the theory as the effect is not only on the flues but also on the seams and crown bolts.

After the rainstorms have ceased, the flues will again resume a normal condition and will give excellent satisfaction with not as much attention as had been pre- viously given them.

For a brief period during the breaking up of winter similar conditions will be observed, until the water gets back again to its normal state.

that time draftsman and man of all work for the late Thatcher Perkins, engineer and superintendent of the company. Be- fore the large machine shop was finished, Mr. Perkins put a small portable engine and boiler and a few tools in the smith shop building, and took a contract to re- build two small engines which had been used on narrow-gage coal roads in the vicinity of Pittsburgh : one of which, be- longing to an operator named Bausman, and which we nicknamed "Bausman's rhinoceros." was the engine shown in the cut. I do not know where or by whom it was designed and built, and thought, when I first saw it, that it would be much better to put it in the scrap pile than to attempt to make anything approaching a practical engine out of it ; but Mr. Perkins did not agree with me, and we took hold of the job.

No drawings of the work have been pre- served, and I have only been able to find a few of my sketches, which show it was for a 3-foot gage, with 24-inch driving wheels, and that the boiler was 33 inches

FIRST WORK OF THE PITTSBURGH LOCOMOTIVE WORKS.

This suggestion is advanced with the aim that some chemist in the railway ser- vice will make an analytical investigation of the supply water at such periods with a view to ascertaining the nature and char- acteristic property of this foreign substance to determine, if possible, the effect it has on the firebox sheets, and to demonstrate the correctness or falsity of this theory. James Fr.\ncis.

Carhondale, Pa.

A Curiosity in Locomotive Design.

The locomotive shown by the accom- panying photograph may be of interest, both because it is the first one upon which any work was done at the Pittsburgh Lo- comotive Works, and as an example of the vagaries into which a departure from standard practice can lead an inexperi- enced designer. It is safe to say that it was the first of its type, and has never been duplicated.

The erection of the original shops of the Pittsburgh Locomotive Works was commenced in 1866. and the writer was at

in diameter at front end. The curious feature about this engine was that it had no main or side rods, the piston rods ex- tending out at both ends of the cylinders and being connected to slotted crossheads, fitted with sliding blocks in which the crank pins worked. The valve gear was of the Carmichael type, used on steam- boats in Scotland very early in the present century. The whole outfit was unme- chanical to the last degree and a most un- promising subject for rebuilding.

We retained the boiler, wheels and axles, threw away the truck and put in new frames and main and side-rod con- nections of tlie ordinary type. Link-mo- tion valve gear could not be used, and there was not even room for V-hooks, so that we were obliged to use drop-hooks and starting bars, and it was a difficult job to get them up. The engine was put into as good shape as such a thing could be brought to, and the night before I left the company's service, I worked the starting bars and found that the hooks dropped on the pins all right, which was the last I

saw of the engine, but I afterwards learned that the company did not get their money back either on her or on the other engine which we rebuilt, owing to a misunder- standing as to the terms of the contract. It is hardly likely that a job of this kind would be offered at the present day, and less likely that any builder would take hold of it if it was.

J. Snowden Bell. Pittsburgh, Pa.

The Apprentice System.

I note your article on the subject of ap- prentices, in your December issue. This is a matter in which I have been very much interested for the past twenty-seven years, and with great success, and am sorry to note that there is not enough- consideration given to the apprenticeship system, either by private firms or railroad companies. They show a lack of interest in imparting the fullest information to the rising generation serving apprenticeships at the different trades. The failure of a firm or corporation to organize a good system for apprenticeship, shows a lack of patience; it requires much patience, and also requires years of time, according to the class of business in which they are em- ployed.

A young man of seventeen or eighteen years, with a good common school educa- tion, is. in my opinion, a fit person for an apprentice at any of the trades, and, with proper attention and encouragement, will prove a valuable investment to his employ- ers. I say proper attention, because care is the watchword to succers in any under- taking.

Be careful to employ only such as are fit for the trade ; this can be determined by taking sufficient time to converse with the lad. Care should be taken that you do not employ them oftener than business will permit. Be careful that they are spaced far enough apart, in order to give them the fullest instruction in the different positions they will pass through during their apprenticeship, and, above all, be careful that you have a good foreman, who has an interest in apprentice boys. If you have not, you had better abandon either the foreman or the boys, as the two must go together — apprentice boys fit for the trade and a foreman fit to instruct the boys. Be careful that you have a fixed plan how they shall be cared for, in order to serve the best interests of the firm or corporation you represent; then. I think, with a little self-interest on the part of the employer properly applied, he will put him- self in a position to meet competition much better, and will have the pleasure of being somewhat of a benefactor to the rising generation.

It is too much the practice, both in rail- road and private shops, to keep an appren- tice in one position, where it appears to them his services are most valuable. This is an injustice to the apprentice, and shows a decided lack of interest on the part of

14

LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEEEIXG

January, 1901.

the firm. There are many apprentice boys who would make bright workmen if they had the proper attention ; and where he does not get the proper attention and in- struction, when serving his apprenticeship, and in after life succeeds in pushing him- self forward and obtaining good positions, he looks backward over the time he was serving said apprenticeship, and feels that he does not owe the firm anything for what he knows.

A four years' term, when the time is well spent in their several positions, is long enough, and apprentices properly looked after will make much better me- chanics, as a rule, than any that are travel- ing around seeking work. In other words, if you want to have good men in your 'shops, spend the time on them for instruc- tion and make your own men.

If this plan is followed out for the next ten or fifteen years. I will guarantee that a good apprenticeship system will receive your hearty support. John Tonge. Master ^Mechanic.

Minneapolis, Minn.

The Old Timer.

Among other changes that have taken place in the train service of railroads that have been keeping abreast of the times for the last decade is the passing from the railroad stage of one of its most prom- inent and interesting characters, the old- time hurricane engineer. He was some- times known as the "Flying Dutchman," the "Wild Irishman," or by some other equally distinctive name suggestive at once of his character and his nationality. His remarkable performances, oft retold, and growing more wondrous with each recital, made him a hero of no little importance in the small world he moved in. and he bore his honors, it seemed to me, with becoming dignity. A decidedly rugged type of man, gruff and unsociable, wasting no time in the cultivation or exercise of polite manners, deeming it his duty to devote every moment of his time whether on or off duty to the company's affairs, at all times using strong language and some- times stronger drinks, he knew no law but the book of rules, and no authority but the superintendent.

But he passed away, -or if still among us has been dethroned by the leveling influ- ence of modern methods and modern ma- chinery, that has made it not only possible but imperatively necessary for all to reach one common standard of efficiency, and beyond that standard there is precious lit- tle room for the most ahibitious to earn applause. This change has robbed the ser- vice of much that made it once so attract- ive and fascinating to the average youth. and is not unlike the playing of a favorite drama without the hero.

The writer well remembers how his first desire to "railroad" was prompted by hearing stories told of the wonderful do- ings of some of these ancient heroes of

the rail, while forming part of an eager, open-mouthed audience of old and young grouped about the stove of the only store in my native town one night a good many years ago. The entertainer of that memo- rable occasion was a man of boasted ex- perience, he having "went along" with shipments of stock on several occasions from "our town" to Philadelphia. He was evidently a recognized authority in our little community on railroading, for his statements were never questioned, and it is safe to say were not even doubted by any of his rural audience.

He told of "one time" that Old Bill Sykes, after having been delayed with the President's Special by a wash-out until he had but fifty minutes left to make im- portant connections at Buffalo, which was sixty miles away, and how Old Bill, after assuring the President that he would bring him in on time, "slammed the lever in the corner, pulled her wide open and let her go." The recital of that story, which was accompanied with all the dramatic ability at the command of our entertainer, almost made my hair stand. He told of how Old Bill dashed around the curve at Brown- ville, striking a team on the crossing, so hard that "they were cut slick and clean from the wagon, and both were carried on the cow-ketcher into Buffalo, where the first stop was made," while the number of cows, dogs and different kinds of fowl that were killed during that memorable trip would make it appear that every creature in the country through which he passed had, for some unaccountable reason, got in the way of that special ; but Old Bill went into Buffalo on time, in spite of all these obstacles. In that fifty minutes Bill's hair, he said, turned perfectly white, and the en- gine, for some reason or other not made clear to me. was never fit for service after that eventful run.

Later on, after I had gone firing, but be- fore the light of wisdom and experience had dispelled from my unsophisticated mind the sweet illusions of boyhood, the question as to what became of Old Bill's fireman often suggested itself to me.

Another story he told was about a Big Pat Hannigan, who, at the beginning of a trial trip with a fast freight train against the time made by a competing line, de- clared to the superintendent, in his cus- tomary forcible but inelegant manner, that he would make it or burn her up in the attempt. He did both. ■ "He burned off every pin on her, dropping her rods ten miles from the terminal, but was going at such a high speed that they drifted into the station over a level track, with five minutes to spare."

This, our narrator added, was Big Pat's last trip. The strain on his nerves proved too much for him, so the president of the road retired him on a liberal pension.

As in the former case. I often wondered what became of Big Pat's fireman.

.As with me, no doubt similar extrava- gant and unlikely stories first awakened

the desire in the breast of many another youth to enter the railroad service, thereby supplying a quality of material eminently fitted, at least by inclination, to develop into high-rolling heroes of the rail.

But alas ! modern methods and improve- ments have brought about the decline, if not the total extinction, of those ideals of our youth, about whose really creditable performances was woven so much of the sensational, the romantic and the ridic- ulous.

The time has not long passed, when, you will agree, running an engine in some localities was an occupation that afforded ample opportunity for the exercise of all the skill and reckless daring that any mai> might possess. That was before the day of the air brake, perfect roadbeds, split switches, reliable engines, double-order system, etc., etc.

The nerve displayed by the old-timer under those conditions, the runs he made — yes, and the wrecks he made — were a continual source of wonder. The former we will mark to his credit, and at the same time excuse him for the major portion of the latter; for the most prejudiced critic must concede that the man was, as a rule, superior to the means supplied him with which to accomplish his task. Then, as now, there was a premium on speed, ex- cepting in odd places. He had of course little to start with, but considerably less with which to stop; and, to quote an irate superintendent who was rendering his de- cision in a case where a train failed to step in time to avoid collision, "The won- der is not that the train was not stopped sooner, but that it ever got stopped at all."

In these times, with all the safeguards surrounding them, the engineers have been reduced — or elevated, if you like — to near- ly a common level. Jack is about as good as Jim or Bill ; and while there is yet an occasional opportunity for the display of superior dash, skill and energy, the result is but like a flash in the pan, when com- pared to the deeds performed by those who led the procession in the "good old days," when luck was a most important factor irj successful railroading.

Thos. p. Whel.\n.

Belleinc. O.

Why Take Down Both Side Rods?

Regarding the exceptions to removing side rods when necessary to disconnect, would like to state that I have presented this question to a large number of engin- eers and am unable to find any who agree with the decision of Mr. C. B. Conger. All manner of reasons have been ad- vanced as to why there are no exceptions to the rule to take off rods on each side if necessary to remove rods on one side, but among the reasons advanced I can see but one that in my opinion is worthy of discussion. I will state it to the best of my ability, and you will kindly answer the same or use your own judgment as to publishing to get the opinions of others.

January. 1901.

LOCOMOTIVE ENGIKEEKlNd

This is the reason : When an engine is on its center or at any other point the main pair of drivers will slip or turn a distance equal to the lost motion in main side rod bushing before turning other wheels, and as main pin leaves the centers main wheels will turn even farther than this, because of the fact that the pin de- scribes an arc as it leaves the centers. The pin will move quite a little way before it would move the other pin. The arc leaves this line at right angles to rod very slowly, depending upon the stroke of engine. If this is a fact, will it not break rods? Of course, if rods are up on each side this

THROTTLE VALVE.

cannot occur. Please give this matter your attention, and oblige.

F. W. Beaird. [The real cause of trouble with a single side rod is that there is nothing to make the two ends act in harmony when start- ing off the center. One end may start moving above the crank pin while the dther moves downward. Then there is grief.— Ed.]

Another Improved Throttle Valve.

We shall have to take a little of the credit away from Mr. Chambers for his new idea in a sectional throttle valve. Sev- eral years ago. while at work at Marshall- town, la., for the Iowa Central, under Master Mechanic M. C. Wheeler, I made and applied to engine No. 25 a sectional throttle valve, a sketch of which is shown in accompanying illustration. At that time thi:^ engine was not equipped with air

brakes and was used as a switch engine. Supposing the continual plugging was in- jurious to the joints in steam chests and steam pipes, I made this valve so when the pressure was greater in dry pipe than in boiler, top section No. 3 would rise and pre>sure in boiler and in dry pipe would equalize. No. I represents a brass-thread- ed plug; No. 2, space between head of stem and shoulder in top section of valve. This space measured J4 inch for lift. No. 4 represents a tapered ground joint, seating in top of No. 5. No. 5 represents the lower section of valve; No. 6, the stem; No. 7. a collar and pin on stem.

JOHX E. OSMER.

Clinton, lo'i.i\j.

Early Recollections.

A short time ago someone had an ar- ticle in the Boston Transcrif't relating to the lease of the Boston & Albany to the New York Central & Hudson River Rail- road, and in it mentioned that there would be but three railroads, viz. : the Boston & Maine, New York, New Haven & Hart- ford and the New York Central, which would enter Boston, other roads being leased to the above.

I often wonder if there are any persons who remember the names of some of the older roads which entered Boston by their own or over other roads, say, twenty-five years ago. The roads probably best re- membered were the Boston & Maine, Bos- ton & Lowell, Boston & Fitchburg, Boston & Worcester, Eastern, Old Colony & Fall River and Boston & Providence.

The Old Colony & Fall River was changed to Old Colony & Newport when extended to that city, and afterwards be- came the Old Colony. Over this road came cars of the South Shore Railroad, Hanover branch and the Cape Cod Cen- tral.

The Boston & Worcester connected both these cities, and later, by lease or other- wise of roads beyond, became the Boston & Albany. It was in the sixties that the cars of the Air Line Railroad, of which Mr. Enos Tucker was superintendent, and who at an advanced age now lives in Need- ham, came to Boston from Woonsocket over a part of the Boston & Worcester ; and the Boston. Clinton & Fitchburg made regular trips from Fitchburg over this road from South Framingham.

On the Boston & Providence could be seen cars of the old Norfolk County Rail- road, which connected Dedham and Black- stone, the Taunton branch (Taunton & Mansfield), New Bedford & Taunton (afterwards New Bedford & Boston), Canton, Stoughton & Fasten (afterwards Canton, Stoughton & Boston).

The Boston & Lowell drew to Boston cars of the Boston, Concord & Montreal : Northern Railroad, Connecticut & Pas- sumsic. Concord Railroad, and probably those of the Nashua, Acton & Boston.

The Boston & Fitchburg (afterward;

Fitchburg Railroad) took charge of the Cheshire Railroad and the Vermont & Massachusetts, the Rutland, and possibly others.

The Boston & Maine and the Eastern were rival roads for years, and probably brought cars of the Portland, Saco & Portsmouth and the Maine Central road, which as late as 1883 advertised in the Boston papers the fact that their cars were of the "monitor-top pattern." They doubt- less felt that, being so far "down East," they were up to date.

For a number of years there was an un- used piece of track between Boston and what is now Islington Junction, on the New York. New Haven & Hartford Rail- road. This road was first called the Mid- land Railroad and afterwards the Boston & New York Central, which failed about 1859 or i860 and became the Boston, Hart- ford & Erie in 1866 or 1867. The road be- came the New York & New England, and later the New England.

On the Boston & Worcester, as late as. 1867, and possibly later, were cars marked "New York & Boston Express Line," and a trip to New York, leaving Boston at 8.30 .•\. M., and drawn as far as Worcester by the Mason engine "Mercury," and arriving in New York at 5.30 P. M., was consid- ered rapid, if stops were made at every station between Boston & Springfield and chances for lunch at Worcester and South Brookfield were thrown in.

It was on the Boston & Worcester Rail- road that cars from the West were seen, these cars having bay windows at every window and the old and reliable Creamer brake, with its hand-wheel resembling a fireman's hat. Who remembers it?

It was in 1867 that the old Norfolk County road ended its usefulness, probably by lease or purchase by the Boston, Hart- ford & Erie, and the old locomotives, "Franklin" and "Blackstone," with the drop-hook valve gearing, became things of the past, their places being taken by McKay and Aldus engines.

"Tell your children of it, and let your children tell their children, and their chil- dren another generation." — Joel, chap, i, verse 3. Herbert Fisher.

Taunton. Mass.

When Mr. W. P. Appleyard, master car builder of the New York, New Haven & Hartford first brought out a passenger car sheathed with copper, Mr. A. E. Mitchell, superintendent of the Erie, was struck with the belief that copper covering was likely to prove a better covering than paint and varnish and he had one car cov- ered in that way for trial. It proved so satisfactory that he now has in service six cars covered with copper. The experience gained with these cars now show that cop- per covering is no longer an experiment, and the Erie people have specified that twenty-nine cars lately ordered for subur- ban service shall be sheathed with copper.

LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING

January, 1901.

A PRACTICAL JOURNAL OF RAILWAV MOTIVE POWER AND ROLLING STOCK.

Published monthly by

ANGUS SINCLAIR CO.,

9S Liberty Street, New York.

Telephone, 984 Co-tiandt.

Cable Address, "Loceng," N

Business Department :

ANOLS SINCLAIR, President. FRED H. CCLVIN. Vice President. JAMES R. PATERSON. Secretary.

Editorial Department :

ANGUS SINCLAIR, Editor. C. B. CONQER, J

F M. NELLIS, FRED H. COLVIN, )

Associate Editors.

Advertising Department :

Eastern Representative— S. I. CARPENTER, 170 Summer St., Boston, Mass.

Chicago Office :

icoo Manhattan Building, E. HILLS in charge.

British Representative :

F. MOORE, 102a Charing Cross Rd., W. C London. ''

SUBSCRIPTION PRICE.

i2.00 fer year, il.oo/or six monllis, fostage paid to any fart o/ the world. Single copies, 20 cents Remit by Express Money Order, Draft, Post Office Order or Registered Letter.

Mailing address can t>e changed as often as neces- sary—always give old and new address, and if you subscribed in a club state who got it up.

Please give prompt notice when your paper fails to reach j ou properly.

Entered at Post Office, New York, as Seconil- class mail matter.

Copyright, 1901.

For Sale by Newsdealers Everywhere.

January Issue,

28,000

Indexes for 1900 will be ready January loth and will be sent on application. Don't hesitate to send a postal card if you want one.

An Addition to Our Name.

With this issue we make a slight addi- tion to the name of this publication, and desire to have it distinctly understood that it is a change in name only. There has been no consolidation, no change in editor- ship or management, and there will be no change in the policy of the paper. It will continue to be the most interesting rail- road paper published, as it has been in the past. The new name simply indicates its developed scope a little more clearly than the old one, and in so doing serves its sole purpose.

Tests of a Locomotive Boiler.

There are so many changing conditions in the operation of a locomotive doing its work on the road that tests made to dem- onstrate the effects of improved propor- tions or appliances are seldom regarded as being absolutely correct. On this ac- count the railroad and engineering world have regarded with keen interest the var- ious contributions to scientific locomotive engineering made by Professor Goss of Purdue University. As most of our read- ers are aware, they have in the engineering

laboratory of Purdue University a com- plete working locomotive mounted on roll- ers, which is run for test purposes under conditions as nearly parallel as possible to the conditions prevailing in train ser- vice. As the engine is equipped with ap- paratus for measuring and recording every detail of the work done, the facts demon- strated may be accepted as correct, a re- sult that has never been reached in road service tests.

At the December meeting of the Ameri- can Society of Mechanical Engineers, Pro- fessor Goss read a paper describing ex- haustive tests of the boiler of the Purdue locomotive which contained very valuable additions to the existing literature on boil- ers and more especially of boilers per- forming the changing duty demanded with locomotives. The boiler is of the wagon- top variety, is 52 inches diameter at waist, has 200 2-inch tubes II feet 5 inches long, has 1.346.9 square feet of heating surface of which 142.6 square feet are in the fire- box and the remainder in the tubes. The grate area is 17.25 square feet. This is the boiler of Schenectady No. i and is comparatively small, for the engine cylin- ders are only 17x24 inches, but the tests made on it give a good comparative idea of the work now being done by the huge engines pulling the trains on our trunk lines. There were particulars of 35 tests given, the duration of test varying from 68 to 25s minutes. The boiler was de- signed to carry 140 pounds gage pressure and during the tests the average varied from 98 to 155 pounds per square inch.

The plan of testing pursued was to work the engine in such a way that the quantity of water evaporation should be increased with each succeeding test so that the efii- ciency of the boiler might be ascertained under the varied conditions of service. In all the tests an effort was made to keep the injector working continuously, but the evaporation was so small in a few of the first tests that the supply of water had to be cut off occasionally. In the first test 5.525 pounds of water were evaporated per hour, and in the last or thirty-fifth test the evaporation was 14,937 pounds per hour. This rate was approximately 250 pounds a minute and was sufficient to evaporate an amount equal to the total water capacity of the boiler in 34 minutes. At this rate, had the injectors been stopped, the water level would have fallen between the upper and middle gages at the rate of one inch per minute. That shows the importance of keeping efficient boiler feeding apparatus on locomotives. In this test the boiler transmitted about 288,000 heat units per minute; that is, heat suffi- cient to raise the temperature of 144 tons of water one degree per minute.

While the engine was working, there were assistants taking the temperature of air. water and smoke-box gases, the tem- perature of the smoke-box under vary- ing conditions and the character of the steam. By the use of a throttling calori-

meter of an improved form taking steam from a perforated pipe extending horizon- tally into the dome of the boiler, it was found that the steam was fairly dry, although its character varied considerably, but the indications are that the amount of moisture in the steam increases with the rapidity of evaporation. The conclusions of Professor Goss on this head read:

"The comparative dryness of the steam under all conditions is a fact worthy of emphasis, for the locomotive is often cred- ited with carrying over a great deal of water to the cylinders. The tests show that this does not happen under constant conditions of running. When it occurs it is probably the result of too high a water level or of a sudden demand upon the boiler. For example, if the throttle of a locomotive, which has been for some time inactive, is quickly opened, large volumes of steam bubbles leave the heating surface and crowd to the upper part of the boiler, making spray in the dome, a portion of which may pass out with the steam. A similar action occurs when an engine which has been working at a light load is suddenly required to increase its power. But these are exceptional conditions. Un- der uniform conditions of running, such as prevailed throughout the tests herein presented, the moisture passing the throt- tle is never great.

"If, as the writer believes, it is fair to conclude that variations in moisture are largely due to incidental conditions, no serious mistake would be made if the in- dications of the calorimeter were entirely disregarded, and all calculations based on the assumption that the steam generated is dry and saturated. Results thus ob- tained should be somewhat more consist- ent, one with another, than those corrected for moisture, and hence for general pur- poses more satisfactory."

The coal used in making these tests was Indiana block, a light friable combustible which burns without clinkers. It contains about 50 per cent, of fixed carbon and 40 per cent, of volatile matter. The quan- tity of coal fired per hour in the different tests varied from 729 pounds to 3,133 pounds. The rate of coal consumption per square foot of grate ranged from 49 to 182 pounds, which is not nearly so high as that of many road engines; but it is relatively high, for marine boilers worked under forced draft rarely burn more than 60 pounds per hour on each square foot of grate, and stationary engine boilers seldom burn more than half that quantity. The evaporative performance of the coal ranged from 10.29 to 6.39 pounds of water to one pound of coal, the low efficiency being when the quantity of water evapo- rated was greatest.

Careful attention was bestowed upon the flow, speed and temperature of the furnace gases. The vacuum in smoke-box varied from 1.7 to 7.5 inches of water. The height of vacuum was very much disturbed by the opening of the fire-box door or the

January, igoi.

LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING

17

closing of the clampers. A thick solid fire (r closed dampers raises the intensity of the draft and an open fire door or light body of fire reduces the pressure of the draft. Locomotive men ought to study these phases carefully for they probably greatly influence the consumption of fuel. The smoke-box temperature varied dur- ing the tests from 550 to 798 degrees Fahr., which was remarkably low, but was no doubt approximately correct.

Professor Goss contended that other things being equal the capacity of the jet as a means of producing draft is nearly proportional to the weight of steam dis- charged per unit of time ; that it makes no difference whether the steam be ex- hausted in the light puffs common to high speed or in the heavy puffs incident to slow speed and heavy work. This does not agree with our experience and we do not think men who have had experience in running locomotives will indorse that part of the paper.

We regret that limited space prevents us from publishing the paper in full, for it contains rich thought-food for those in- terested in the economical operation of the locomotive engine.

To Investigate Draft Gear.

The most important question before the railroad world at present is, What can be done to prevent freight trains from break- ing in two? It is now generally acknowl- edged that the draft gear is the weakest part of a freight car and that little has been done to strengthen that part of the structure in proportion to the increasing weight of cars and locomotives and the re- sulting severity of shocks that have to be endured by the draft gear. With the long heavy trains that are now hauled on so many railroads, the shocks thrown upon the draft attachments are terrific. When the violence of the shock is measured, the surprise is not that failures of the draft gear are common, but that the connections stand so well as they do. The Erie Rail- road Company made a series of tests a short time ago for the purpose of ascer- taining the extent of shocks transmitted to the draft gear. A dynamometer car was used which had a gage graduated to re- cord a shock of 78,000 pounds, yet the con- cussions put upon the draft timbers re- peatedly exceeded that limit of measure- ment. When such blows are frequently imparted in the handling of cars it is no wonder that the repair yards are chroni- cally crowded with cars waiting to have broken drawbars replaced and damaged draft gear repaired.

Among the committees of investigation appointed by the Master Car Builders' As- sociation is one on Draft Gear and Coup- lers. Mr. E. D. Bronner, superintendent of motive power of the Michigan Central, is chairman of that committee, and he has started upon the work in a fashion which promises to bring forth information that

will be of great service to railroad com- panies. The Executive Committee of the Master Car Builders' Association have authorized Mr. Bronner to spend $1,500, or more if necessary in making tests of draft gear, and he has employed Mr. R. H. Soule, the well-known expert engineer, to supervise the work. He will hold meet- ings at various times and places, and the intention is to invite people well informed concerning draft rigging and drawbar mat- ters to attend these meetings and give the committee the benefit of their experience. The Westinghouse Air-Brake Company have offered the use of a train and various apparatus to be employed in making the tests, and the generous offer is likely to be accepted. The Westinghouse Air-Brake Company have a friction buffer which has given extraordinary results in reducing the shocks imparted to the draft gear. That apparatus will be thoroughly tested, but all other forms of improved draft gear will also be investigated, and the experiments carried out will be sufficient to show the strength and weakness of the various parts constituting the draft gear. There is some diversity of opinion among railroad officials about how strong the draft ap- pliances ought to be made. Some men hold that the draft gear should be made strong enough to resist the severest shocks to which it is subjected, while others think that it ought merely to be made strong enough to endure average shocks without breakage. Some people believe that the draft gear proper should be as strong as the draft timbers to which it is secured, while others hold that the 'raft gear should be weak enough to yield in case of col- lision without damaging the draft timbers. It is time that more light were thrown upon these questions, and we believe that Mr. Bronner's committee will give forth this enlightenment.

Rigid and Flexible Center Trucks.

One of the most common subjects of discussion among railroad-car men used to be "What is the relative cost of maintain- ing rigid center and swing-beam trucks?" Investigation seemed to show that the swing-beam truck was much more ex- pensive to repair than one with rigid cen- ter. The old swing-beam truck was an article of very inferior construction, and it failed because some of its parts were in- herently weak and there were too many of them.

In a discussion on this subject at a club meeting some ten years ago, a leading member said : "We have decided on the score of economy to abandon the swing- beam truck. We have done this in the interests of both safety and economy after careful investigation. We found that the parts of our trucks that were constantly needing more repairs than others were the hangers and axles which are attached to the hangers. These axles are breaking so frequently that the question was raised

whether we should not increase their size, but then the question came up why have them at all? This is a kind of question which comes up often in mechanics. Take locomotive rod connections, for instance. We used to shear a great many bolts, break straps and lose keys, all of which led to accidents and high cost of repairs. In searching for a remedy for this, the question was raised, why have them at all? If we can do away with them there will be no bolts to shear or keys and straps to cause delay and expense. The change was made with decided benefit to the com- pany.

"The same policy was adopted with the swing-motion truck, and a few years' ex- perience proved that we had done the right thing. That policy was largely adopted by other railroads, and there are now com- paratively few swing-motion trucks under freight cars."

From various causes there has arisen of late a doubt among many men about the abandoning of the swing-beam truck hav- ing been as wise a move as it was reputed to be. With increase in the weight of cars and the general introduction of the vertical plane coupler new difficulties in train operating have arisen which some people think might have been obviated by use of a swing-motion truck. There are a great many delays from cars uncoupling in passing curves, and sometimes the cars leave the track owing to the rigid charac- ter of coupler and truck, and it is rea- soned that a flexible truck might prevent that There is also no little trouble from cut wheel flanges and flanges broken off and the advocates of the flexible truck insist that it would have a remedial effect here also. There are some flexible trucks on the market now that have no more parts than a rigid truck. They have no hangers, no support pins and no sand board. It is possible that some of them may yet largely displace the rigid center truck, especially if experience dem- onstrates that they will decrease the in- voluntary uncoupling of cars.

Railroad Rates Too Low.

We have received, through the courtesy of Mr. George H. Daniels, general passen- ger agent of the New York Central, a pamphlet, by D. Car-Skaden, on "Do American Railways Pay?" It gives very interesting and instructive reading. The fact seems clearly proven that railroad companies in America charge too low rates for transportation to leave a fair margin of profit. The pamphlet concludes :

"How railway corporations can sustain further adverse legislation, and further reductions in transportation tariffs, coupled with advanced prices for all material en- tering into construction, repairs and re- newals— averaging 40 to 50 per cent, high- er than in 1898 — with the constant demand for improvements in every department, and maintain their present high standard

i8

LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING

January, igoi.

of efficiency for service and safety, is a question more easily asked than answered. States enact laws governing rates, but no provisions are made for such exigencies as at present exist. There must be a critical point somewhere, that even the general law of increasing returns cannot compen- sate. If the earnings for i8g8 are a cri- terion, the advanced cost of material and labor for 1900 indicates that such a stage has already been reached; and if so re- maining, these indispensable quasi-public institutions, representing between one- cigh.h and one-ninth of the whole wealth of the country, will not only not be the beneficiaries of even a moiety of the pres- ent prosperity to which they are certainly entitled, but will be in danger of sustain- ing a loss instead. That percentage of re- ceipts which would otherwise afford a legitimate profit will be fully -absorbed by increased expenses. To avoid such a re- sult, one of two courses must ensue — either rates must be proportionately raised or maintenance and efficient service ne- glected, the latter of which, at best, is merely a postponement, for the time being, of the evil day of reckoning and disaster, inflicting more or less injury upon the whole community."

The Iniquitous Line Car.

There is something strange about the way that railroad companies allow them- selves to be imposed upon by private car line companies. It is notorious that own- ers of line cars frequently make more money for the btisiness they do than the railroad companies that haul the cars. Then it seems to be the settled policy of line car owners to put no more repairs upon their cars than they can help and the consequence is that accidents frequently happen through the air brakes on line cars being out of order. If fewer railroad offi- cers were stockholders in line car compa- nies, it would be much better for railroad companies.

A paper was read at the Northwestern Railway Club lately on line cars, and the following points were made during the discussion of the paper:

"There is no doubt a large amount of money lost by the railroad companies in repairing private line cars. This is largely due to claims made by the private line companies for improper repairs. Quite a large amount of improper repairs are made by the railroad companies, but it is almost impossible to do otherwise. Many cars owned by private car lines come into various yards, and there are so many standard parts that it is impossible to tell just the proper standard, therefore the railroad company makes the repairs which its men think are standard for the car, and when the car gets home they get a joint evidence card and bill against the company making the repairs. This is car- ried to such an extent that in one case a joint evidence card was presented with a claim for wrong repairs for a brass which

was applied in the early part of May and the proper repairs were made in October by the company owning the car. After nearly seven months' service the brass was taken out on account of "wrong repairs Lnd the railroad company was called upon to pay for the so-called improper repairs."

"The case of the brass brings to my mind the fact that I have never been able to reach anybody who will at any time be responsible for the private line car. For imtance, we receive a private line car from a connecting line with missing material which is chargeable to the company deliv- ering. Why can't we get a release card from it covering the defects? Nobody seems willing to take the responsiblity and this is particularly the case of private line cars coming over transfer lines."

"It is very rarely that we can get one of the private line companies to inspect a car that is going to be loaded. Not one of the firms in the city has got a car man. When we go to inspect a car that is going to be sent over our line, it is seldom that we can find a line car that is fit to go out without some repairs. If we ask the people connected with the line what they are going to do about the cost of repairs they disclaim all responsibility and say that it does not belong to their departments. In nine cases out of ten. railroad companies have not got the proper material to repair those cars, and if you make the repairs to accommodate the owner the railroad com- pany has to pony a bill on account of using wrong material."

All of this goes to show that private line car companies employ officials who delib- erately combine to cheat railroad compa- nies.

Another Hot Water Mo(or.

"Hope reigns eternal in the human breast." says some poet. We think it reigns more eternally in the breasts of some inventors than it does with any other class of people. The more idiotic and more im- practical an invention may be the more fiercely the inventor is moved to proclaim that he has discovered something of a wonderful character that is going to revo- lutionize some industry and hurl into oblivion devices, appliances and engines which are doing their work satisfactorily to all concerned except to the unbalanced inventor.

No invention has been more persistently threatened with a dip into the waters of lethe (oblivion) than the locomotive, but it persistently keeps at work and declines to be suppressed by its enemies who are financially interested in would-be substi- tutes of untried utility. The latest can- didate for the place occupied by the loco- motive has recently been exploited in the pages of a New York yellow journal under sensational captions such as: "Power stored in water may supplant the locomo- tive ! Smoke, cinders and noise of the

locomotive may soon be things of the past. System is undergoing trial tests on the New York & Putnam Railroad, etc."

When we descend to read particulars about the system, we find it to be the su- perheated water humbug which has been haunting railroad men for years, boring them with big promises and realizing rid- iculous failures. There is a motor car in the engine house of the New York & Putnam Railroad which is designed to use superheated water as motive power, but its most notable achievement has been going out a few miles and waiting till a switch engine came to haul it back. We may be sure that that performance will not be mentioned by the parties offering to sell stock in the company. We admit that there is useful energy stored up in super- heated water, but it is not adapted for railroad motive power purposes.

Diversity of Car Couplers.

When the Master Car Builders' type of coupler was adopted, it was supposed that the new form would lead towards uni- formity in shapes, but the reverse seems to be the case. There used to be so many kinds of link and pin couplers that rail- road companies had difficulty in carrying at interchange points the diversity of coup- lers necessary for effecting repairs. When it was proposed to establish a standard type of coupler, many people voted for it in the expectation that the move would conduce to uniformity, and it must be very annoying now to find that confusion is becoming worse confounded through di- versity of knuckles. That is the part of the coupler that breaks most frequently, and there are said to be from 60 to 70 kinds of knuckles already in use with new ones emerging monthly from the in- ventor's mill.

It seems to us that it is high time that the Master Car Builders' Association should step in and put a restraint upon the tendency to increase the diversity of coup- ler knuckles. The M. C. B. coupler has been long enough in use to demonstrate the forms of knuckles that give least trou- ble in service. That being the case, it is the duty of the M. C. B. Association to select eight or ten of the most satisfactory couplers and admit them as standards of the Association. All others should be denied interchange privileges. The M. C. B. Association have refused to recognize brakes that do not meet certain require- ments. A similar policy ought to be adopted in regard to car couplers.

Another Freak.

If Mr. Gilderfluke liad waited a couple of years he would have added a pneumatic engine to that wonderful creation of genius he showed some time ago. True, he might have had to pay a royalty to the Hopkins Pneumatic Auxiliary Engine Company, of Lithonia, Ga., but that would not deter a man like Gilderfluke from adopting the latest and most approved devices.

January. 1901

LOCOMOTIVr-: f^xgineering

19

This is an air-compressor cylinder placed in front of the main cylinder, tandem fashion, in which air is compressed and stored in tanks "put in any convenient place" (.there are lots of convenient places lying around loose for tanks on the loco- motives of to-day), and air is stored for future use — not for braking trains (that's an old scheme), but for helping the engine out of a tight place and prevent her lying down on the hill with a string of loads be- hind her. It only adds two levers in the cab, two more piston-rod packings on each side and a lot of wimbal joints that delight the repairman when work is slack. Of course the main object of the device is to compress the air on down grades to secure braking effect, and then give back the work on up grades. But we have serious doubts as to its general adoption in the near future for either purpose.

BOOK NOTICE.

"Tl;e Progress of Invention in the Nine- teenth Century." By Edward W. Byrn. A. M. Munn & Co., New York. Price. $3C0.

This is a book of 476 pages. 6V2 x g'/i inches, and covers an immense scope of subjects, as may be inferred from the title. The author is very modest in his claims for the work, saying that it is simply a cursor}' view of the century in the field of invention, intended to present the broader bird's-eye view of progress achieved. The book is based largely upon Patent Office reports, but that is not a bad blemish, for the bare chronology of leading inventions produced during the nineteenth century represents such a stupendous picture of human achievement that the industrial triumphs of all other centuries sink into insignificance by comparison. Invention and scientific research had scarcely com- menced when people first began to write 1800 en the few letters sent through the post offices. War and strife occupied the first place in men's minds, and the arts and agriculture carried on gave little incentive to ambition. ' But a feeble spirit of in- quiry was awake. The common schools, that had been planted like light-giving rays all over the United States and a few other countries, were developing the men- tal faculties of classes who were not bound by the shackles of "let well enough alone." Independent thought was growing, and it started the rills of inventive effort and scientific research, which gradually in- creased in force and magnitude until they reach the shores of the twentieth century as great rivers. The chronical table of leading inventions makes edifying reading itself, and proves that mechanical inven- tions and researches in chemistry were the leading forces that revolutionized the world. In 1800 there are two inventions mentioned as being worthy of notice, viz. : Volta's chemical battery for producing electricity and Roberts' machine for mak- ing continuous webs of paper. In 1801 mention is made of the first automobile,

which was Trevithick's steam coach. Be- sides that there were Brunei's mortising machine. Jacquard's pattern loom, Scott's first fireproof safe and the discovery by Hatchett of columbium. The book con- tains thirty-eight chapters, each one de- voted to some particular line of invention. In going over these we are surprised at the amount of attention bestowed upon some lines of industry and the meagre treatment of others that the world regards as of greater importance. The author must have used English reference books largely, for we notice that he ignores im- portant American inventors and gives the credit to others. He never mentions what Oliver Evans had done with the steam en- gine or anything else, and credits the in- vention of the high-pressure steam engine to Trevithick. His chapter on the "Steam Railway" is ridiculous, both in brevity and in inaccuracy. He says that the multi- tubular boiler was invented by Seguin in 1828. when everyone familiar with the his- tory of invention knows that it was in- vented by Nathan Read, a New England man, in 1788, Peter Cooper put a tubular boiler on his small locomotive built for the Baltimore & Ohio in 1829, but the author does not mention Cooper's work. The book says that the link-motion invention was claimed by the younger Stephenson and by W. T. James, of New York. The so-cal'ed Sterhen-on link motion was in- vented by Howe, a patternmaker in the employ of Stephenson & Son, and no one else claimed to be the inventor. When men ignorant about details of the history of locc motive development are at a loss to tell who invented some particular de- vice, the}' are ready to attribute it to the Stephenscns. We are, then, not surprised to see that the author of this book says that Stephenson was the inventor of the steam whistle. It is well known that the first steam whistle was invented by Ad- rien Stevens, an engineer connected with the Dowlais Iron Works, in Wales. It was first applied to a locomotive by Bury, one of the early English locomotive build- ers. Another chapter of the book that displeases us is that devoted to wood- working machinery. Outside of the saw, the art of wood working by machinery was alnio t entirely developed by .Amer- ican invention and genius ; but this book would lead one ignorant on the subject to believe that all the important wood-work- ing machines that now fill our planing mills were invented in England. There is a chaper called "Metal Working." which is a misncmer, for it ought to be called "Metallurgj-," as it is devoted entirely to metallurgical operations. Although ma- chine tool making is one of the most im- portant industries in the United States, it is scarcely mentioned in the book. These and other omissions and mistakes are bad blemishes ; but still the book is a valu- able contribution to the industrial litera- ture of the last year of the nineteenth cen- tury.

Examination for Promotion.

We are requested to answer so many questions that belong to the examination code of the Traveling Engineers' Associa- tion that we have decided to publish the questions with the answers as they appear in Sinclair's "Locomotive Engine Running and Management." The questions were originally compiled by a committee of the Traveling Engineers' Association for the guidance of the members, but no answers were given. A set of answers was pre- pared by Mr. M. M. Meehan, and they were afterwards expanded by Mr. C. B. Conger and Mr. Angus Sinclair. They will be continued monthly until the whole code is completed. As published in the book mentioned they read as follows :

Q. I. — What is a locomotive?

A. — A steam engine placed on wheels and producing power to move itself and draw cars on a railway. For convenience in operating, there are tv.o high-pressure engines coupled to the same wheels.

Q. 2.— rWhat are your first duties when going out of the house with an engine?

A. — To see that there is sufficient water in the boiler, that gage cocks and water glass are working properly, firebox flues tight, the fire in good order, ash-pan clean, that there are proper tools on the engine for use in regular service, also for cases of accident. If I did not bring the engine in last trip, I should inspect the engine thoroughly for any defects that might cause trouble on the trip ; look on the report book and see what work the last man reported, and note what work has been done.

Q. 3. — What tools do you consider necessary?

A. — All the tools usually supplied on this road for regular service, firing tools included; such tools and blocking as are required in case of accident; oil cans and signal lamps.

Q. 4. — What supplies?

A. — Coal, water, sand, oil. waste, pack- ing, e.xtra glass globes and any material you r ust use regularly on the trip.

Q. 5. — How do you locate a pound in an engine?

A. — Place the engine on the top quarter, block driving wheels, have the fireman give engine a little steam and reverse her ; watch all points on that side where she is liable to pound. If the axle pounds in box, you can see the wheel hub move without moving box ; if wedge is down or pedestal bolts loose, the box will move sidewise on the shoe and wedge. If it is not located in the boxes or rods, look at key holding piston rod in cross-head, or spider may be loose on piston rod. It is difiicult to locate this trouble unless you have once heard it, as the pound is not al- ways the same at each end of the stroke; it depends on how the spider or piston is fastened on the rod.

Q. 6. — If pound is in the rods, can you always locate it?

A. — Yes, in the way just mentioned.

LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING

January, 1901.

Q. 7- — How would you commence to key-up a mogul or ten-wheel engine?

A. — Place engine on center, so pins would be the same distance apart as cen- ters of axles, to get the side rods the exact length ; key-up the middle connection of side rod first, then the front and back, as they can more easily be adjusted the proper length. For main rod, stand on the quarter; if the crank pins are not worn out of round, any position will do.

Q. 8. — If the pound is in the wedges, can you set them up and get them right the first trial?

A. — Most always.

Q. 9. — How do you do this?

A. — Have the engine on straight track, so the boxes would not cramp the wedges ; place that side on the top quarter, give en- gine steam or pinch wheel to move box away from wedge and against shoe; set wedge up till it is tight between box and jaw of frame, then draw it down about % inch, so box can move up and down freely. Or have two helpers ; take pinch- bars, use one each side of driver; when both raise at once, wheel and box will raise. Set up wedge till box sticks, then slack it down till box moves freely.

Q. 10. — Will an engine pound if pedes- tal bolts are loose?

A. — Yes. With a Baldwin engine or any build that has the brace bolted to hook over the bottom of jaws; if bolts work loose, it will let the brace and wedge down. If there is a large bolt runs from one jaw to the other, like the Manchester or Rhode Island engines, the wedge can- not drop down, as it is held up by the thimble which goes on the pedestal bolt between the jaws ; but the jaws will spread apart if bolt gets loose, and let box pound.

Q. II. — Where wedge bolts are broken, how do you keep the wedge in position?

A. — If there is a jam-nut or wedge bolt on top of pedestal brace, and bolt breaks on top of this nut, it can be spliced by run- ning the nut up over the break and putting a washer equal to half the thickness of nut between it and the brace, thus having half the nut each side of break ; this will not hold the wedge from going either up or down. Or a nut of the right size can be put between the wedge and brace and tied with a piece of wire through the hole in nut. This will hold wedge from coming down.

Cheaper and Quicker.

In response to an invitation to bid on some locomotives to be built for the State railways of India, the lowest bid from an English builder was $1,000 higher for each locomotive than the bid of the lowest -American manufacturer. The English bnilder asked for nine months in which to do the work. The American contracted to do it in six.

Conserving Effect of Westingliouse Friction Draft Gear.

On October 14, 1900, between 11 and 11.30 P. M., a collision occurred, under the following circumstances, in the Ana- conda yard of the Butte, Anaconda & Pa- cific Railway :

Switch engine No. 3 was coupled to seven loaded pressed-steel ore cars at the east end of the yard, being on a side track. A man had been left to open the west

The coupler was the "Standard," with solid knuckle.

All of the cars were fitted with the Westinghouse friction draft gear — not one of which attachment, even on the colliding cars, was damaged in the least.

The opposite from the colliding ends of the two cars mentioned had slight kinks in the center sills, near the body bolster; the striking plate and end sill were bent in about 7-16 inch, just back of the coupler

#^»

"^m^

«*i«»Mii«rt*i5

^<f^=^im^

^^^^^m \

/,-

^Jirf^B"^-^

ONE OF THE CARS IN COLLISION.

The Rock Island Railroad is said to be bidding for an important mail contract for carrying the United States mail.

switch, and, under the assumption that the track was clear, the engineer was given a signal to come ahead (west), pushing the cars. Twenty-nine similar cars (loaded) were at the other end of the siding, about three-quarters of a mile from where the seven were coupled to. As a result, a col- lision followed. No time for warning was had, and the seven cars and engine were moving at about 13 miles per hour, with the latter working steam. Under ordinary circumstances, the air brakes would have been set on the twenty-nine cars, and it is therefore assumed that such was a fact, though the number of cars showing evi- dence of having received a very severe shock gives rise to some doubt on this point.

The resultant injury to equipment con- sisted of the colliding ends of the two cars being considerably damaged, the worst being illustrated by the accompany- ing photograph — being of the seventh, or last, car from the engine. The damage to the other car was so much less as to en- able its being readily repaired by straight- ening the longitudinal sills and applying a new end sill. To facilitate this work (as repair material had to be ordered from Pittsburgh), the end sill was removed from the car illustrated — this being shown by the other photograph.

At the colliding ends, one coupler was broken in the shank, close to the head, and the other had the guard-arm broken off.

head, and the coupler locking pin was wedged from the blow received through the knuckle of the opposite coupler. In twenty-nine cars, thirty-seven locking pins were so wedged. These were driven out, slightly ground, and returned to their couplers. About twenty cars had the cen- ter sills injured as described, but in no instance was the damage sufficient to re- quire any repairs.

The average load of these ore cars is 110,000 pounds, their light weight is 34,800 pounds, and the engine, with tender, weighed about 150,000 pounds. For the engine and seven cars this makes a total of 1,163,600 pounds. At 13 miles per hour, and neglecting the effect of the steam being used, this represents a strik- ing force of 6,575,000 foot-pounds, which is equivalent to the blow one of these lio.- ooo-pound-capacity steel cars, fully loaded and weighing 72^^ tons, would strike if dropped freely from a height of 54 feet. Even though no brakes were set on the twenty-nine standing cars, yet their great weight and small amount of slack be- tween them insure that the enormous amount of energy in engine and seven cars moving must have been dissipated in an exceedingly short distance.

That this was followed by such compara- tively slight damage is a splendid tribute to the Westinghouse friction draft gear, to which Master Mechanic A. Harrity gives unbounded praise. While reducing greatly

January, 1901.

LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING

the consequent damage, it came out un- scathed.

Nor should the strength of the car or coupler pass unnoticed, though the weak- est points in each, under buffing shocks, were demonstrated to be as described. The coupler has a 6-inch shank, in this being out of the ordinary.

Some Ideas on Road Supervision.

BY EUGENE m'.\ULIFFE.

On a great many railroads there exists to-day a condition that does not tend to materially increase the footing of that much watched column of figures known as "net earnings." Economy has of late years been the watchword of the railway world ; but, unfortunately, in a great many instances the honest and well-meant efforts of many officials to that end have not met with complete success. On some special lines, it is true, remarkable showings have been made, but often such specialization

the cheapest engine. It matters not as to whether she excelled on any special item — that can readily be done — but it is the total cost that tells the true story.

Human nature is a fixed quantity. That must be taken as we find it, and it rests with the man whose talent, broadness and honesty of purpose have placed him at the head, to direct subordinate effort in the right channel, which, in railway service, lies in the line of the greatest possible earning consistent with fair and consider- ate treatment of the public, its patrons and dependent employes.

In discussing economies the writer only desires to touch on such points as the men employed in the mechanical and operating departments are directly concerned with.

Land, legal, claim, telegraph, soliciting and other departments cover particular fields, but while the mechanical depart- ment of a great many roads is held, in a niLasure, secondarv to all, or at least the

RESULT OF COLLISION.

has resulted in the partial or complete neglect of richer fields, with cents saved that might have been dollars if the effort made had been otherwise directed.

It requires no special talent to produce a showing on some one line or in one de- partment, if the welfare of all others is made subordinate to the favored one. This disregard of the welfare of the whole in many instances is not intentional, but is brought about by the fact that some par- ticular man is of the opinion that his de- partment is of greater importance than any other or that a personal showing is of greater consequence than a general show- ing. When the end of the year comes, with it? figures, a balance favorable or un- favorable, it is the net side that counts, and the man who best keeps that in view is the most valuable man. Going down to smaller matters, on the same principle, the engine that runs the most miles or moves the largest tonnage for the least money is

operating department, there is one time when it rises above all else in importance; that is when the cry "retrenchment" is passed down the line.

The fact that the mechanical department is so unfortunate as to consume the major part of the operating expense will always serve to maintain its importance. Econ- omy in the use of lubricants, fuel and other supplies has in the past, and yet offers rich fields ; but the cost of running repairs to locomotives, the expense en- tailed by the rough handling of cars, in- judicious speeds at certain times and places, losses by fire and stock claims, in- juries to the patrons and employes of the road, avoidable delays to trains, both freight and passenger, with a consequent loss of patronage and business prestige, are all points that deserve attention, but which seem in a great many cases to be partially neglected. A gentleman prom- inent in the railroad world a short time

ago touched on that greatest of all econ- omies, rarely spoken of, but much prac- ticed, viz. : the economy of truth. Per- haps less economy in that line, together with less disposition to shoulder trouble-, on some other person, without the sug- gestion of a remedy for the complaint, and a more thorough understanding of the fact that the same paymaster pays us all to a common end, could be called the essence of the whole situation.

An increased demand for heavier ton- nage induced by keen, aggressive compe- tition, heavy business, the shortage of en- gines and cars, the marked and startling increase of weight and capacity of much of the new power recently purchased, the complete transfer of labor, skill and re- sponsibility involved in the control of trains from the hand to power brakes and from train to enginemen, have all com- bined to produce an intense condition which requires the full and hearty co- operation of everyone from the call-boy to the general manager, if the desired result would be secured. It is hard to foresee the result of innovations or how perplex- ing the complications born of new and strange conditions may become. For in- stance, the advent of locomotives with a tractive capacity of from 40 to 70 per cent, in excess of those to which engine, train, track men and dispatchers are accustomed to, at times results in the apparent tem- porary demoralization of all forces.

The average man is willing and anxious to keep step with the times, but he be- comes partially lost; and nothing but the direct supervision of men who have capa- city to encourage and lead will avoid at least partial panic.

The introduction of heavier engines, re- quiring more skill in handling, and the proper diagnosis of special complaints, greater physical effort, longer hours, with the compensation fixed at the old standard and requiring time for adjustment; the feeling that the new condition is forcing men out of employment, the feeling en- gendered by road and office men unable each to meet the expectations of the other, all victims of a common condition, suggest a state of affairs requiring the presence of the leader. Railway organization is very similar to military organization, and the rank and file, generally speaking, evince the same willingness to follow loyally the leader who has their confidence and re- spect. No superintendent has yet dared string a schedule so fast chat his engineers would not make up time if the means were given them ; and. on the same principle, the American engine and train man will meet any other proposition offered, if rightly approached.

Believing that the ends of economy and the highest possible grade of service would be best obtained by the closer relation of department to department, and the de- partments in turn to the men, the writer would urge the consolidation of the duties of subordinate staff officials. They are so

LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERINO

January, 1901.

numerous as to be able to give every man and every new condition close personal at- tention. There are hundreds of train- masters to-day who act as judge, jury and executioner en thousands of men involved m accidents, in the arbitrament of whose (;a!"es a knowledge of the locomotive, air brake and train handling is a necessity, but who are more innocent of these things than the youngest brakeman. These men are not foTs, but unfortunately have been t-ained on other lines to the exclusion of :he one they now most need.

I have one man in particular in mind vhose calendar is never clear. The raa- j irity of cases consist of trains parting, engine failures, air-brake failures (mostly imaginary), delays to important trains, I tc, and in deciding on the disposition of ihese cases he in a measure gropes in the dark. Again, traveling engineers and air- b -ake instructors in their journey over iheir districts notice conditions relating to I he operating department, and trainmas- •,ers to the mechanical department, but, confined within fixed limits they take no notice of the matter — in fact it is often the part of discretion not to do so.

When a rush of business comes, perhaps .■It a season when it is difficult to maintain power in the best possible condition, the f ilure to handle this volume of business creates some trouble.

.'\t times one department feels that the other is not doing its share, and vice versa. The men think that they are being mis- used, and a reign of indifference com- mences, that does not help much toward a betterment. At this point the subordinate staff organization should be of most value, working for the company. Constantly in the field, they certainly should be able to convey fairly to the proper parties the true status of affairs.

The combining of the positions of train- master or assistant trainmaster, road fore- m:in of engines and air-brake instructor, suggests an arrangement that deserves S3rae consideration, offering what seems to be the most feasible plan to furnish the necessary go-between to official and man, a staff organization that, properly organ- ized, should be most effective in bringing the service up to the highest standard, or under extremely adverse circumstances making the avoidance of a condition of semi-demoralization possible. With a suffi- cient number of men to admit of giving each man just such territory as he can well handle, meeting the men and covering the ground frequently, it should not be difficult to secure such knowledge as would materially increase the capacity of the head of each department, with the addi- tional satisfaction of knowing that reme- dial measures adopted would be fairly ap- plied. There is no reason why a man who is informed on locomotive and brake prac- tice should not be informed on train rules and handling, competent to pass fairly on all complex questions. As to the matter of economv. such a man could, when rid-

ing i;n an engine or train, observe the conJitijn and handling of both engine and air brakes, noting defects and giving the proper instruction to engine and train men ; observe the use and misuse of fuel and supplies; note manner of performing road work by train men and agents, the conditi:^n of road bed and other fixed property — in fact, all the work that three men, each trying to cover a larger terri- tory and but poorly able to do so, would do, with the capacity to apply or suggest a remedy without treading on someone's corns. This man would work for the company direct, and having no one to un- load on, would meet each issue squarely as it came up. This man often by close asso- ciation with the men could learn of their small but vexing troubles, avoiding many times the convening of grief committees that usually come away with something. The taking of employes into a partial con- fidence is a plan that would beget much more intelligent and loyal service. Often railway officials, struggling to bring a poor property up to a pacing basis, could add materially to the effectiveness of a fixed but Ijmited number ot cars and en- gines, if the manager could, through the proper channel, get his desires before the men. Ten hours are but ten hours, but men can and will do more in that time if properly attuned than otherwise. Many men have thought the pooling of engines was brought about by indigestion or such that the Old Man was a sufferer from, when the facts were that the road was compelled to refuse paying business for lack of power, the profit from this business possibly changing a deficit to an earning — something very necessary to the purchase of more power.

Such an organization could also arrange systems of education and examination on train rules, machinery, etc.. without which the greatest incentive toward study is lacking.

The questions that could be met in this way are endless. The plan has been pro- nounced practical by many able railroad men. The only question raised is, Can the right men be had? When matters of im- portance are discussed, the personal quan- tity must be left out. The man who is most valuable, who can earn the most should be chosen. If nepotism or friend- ship is to decide the selection, the effort will prove futile. If the material does not exist to-day, create the demand, and with this as with any other line, the demand will be filled when the way is pointed.

New Locomotives for the New York Central.

At a meeting of the Board of Directors of the New York Central, on December 20th, President Callaway was authorized to contract for 100 new locomotives of the first class. These new engines will be ordered at the discretion of the president. and are reported to cost about $1,200,000. thus averaging $12,000 each.

Women Railway Officials.

"Sometimes railroad companies depart from all rules and traditions and make in- novations that, to say the least, are rather startling," said an old Kansas City rail- read man recently, in a conversation with a reporter.

"It's only a few years since the Southern Pacific saw the sudden collapse of what seemed a very promising experiment, yet now it has another, and in this case, too, the results so far are very satisfactory.

"Ten or a dozen years ago 'Old Charlie Crocker,' as he was familiarly called by al- most eve.'y employe of the Southern Pa- cific, as a reward for a particularly daring and meritorious act, prevailed on the di- rectorate of the Southern Pacific to edu- cate a young girl. She had lived almost all her life in the mountains of New Mexico, with almost no associates except her father, an engineer, and his fireman. She was a railroad girl from top to toe, and her knowledge of railroad craft enabled her to avert what would have been a most fright- ful wreck. Her reward was an education such as few girls in her station in life ever obtain. Everything one of the finest edu- cational institutions in the West could do was done for her. and at the completion of the college term she was, at her own re- quest, given a post-graduate course in me- chanical engineering. Her schooling fin- ished, she was given a position in the office of the superintendent of motive power at a nice salary, which was looked upon by the men in the office as a kind of pension. It was supposed that she would, in office parlance, 'hold the chair,' and that her time would be occupied by purely technical duties, but the yoimg woman soon proved she was worth more than her salary. One day, within a year of her graduation, she submitted plans and specifications for a new type of engine. There were a number of new ideas in the plans and some decid- ed improvements, and it was just the thing the company had been looking for. Some of the best mountain passenger engines the Southern Pacific ever had were built from that set of plans.

"It was a rude shock to the masculine element in that office that 'the girl' should carry off the honors they thought were safely their own, and then they fell to wondering what this phenomenal girl would do next. She did what they all do if the right man comes along. One day a b'g official of an Eastern railroad came through the office. No one ever knew how it happened, but the bright light of the motive-power staff' swapped mechanics for matrimony. An experiment with the 'new woman' was closed, and the 'first lady me- chanic' was transformed into what she is to-day — a very happy wife.

"Not until a little over two years ago did the staid old management take another plunge into officially unknown waters. Then when Spanish treachery raised the cry. 'Remember the ]\Iaine.' and all the patriotic instincts of the sons of Uncle

January, 1901.

LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING

23

Sam were at boiling point. O. F. Pease, the trainmaster at Gila bend. N. M.. lumped out and put his name on the mus- ter roll of the First Territory Cavalry. Be- t'ore he left he wired his resignation and turned the office over to his wife, who for years before her marriage, had been a tele- graph operator on the line. AH her married !ife she has been doing more or less of the clerical work of the office. Gila Bend is a little place in the middle of a long divi- sion, lonesome as only a coal and water -■lation in the great American desert can be. and it was almost impossible to keep ;i clerk there for any length of time. In the interval between the departure of one clerk and the arrival of his successor Mrs. Pease learned all the details of the office work, and, on the departure of her hus- band, it was a very handy knowledge.

"Just at that time the road was rushed to its utmost capacity by the enormous

tered, but almost backed out again. I thought I had got into someone's family quarters. There was a carpet on the floor and pretty white curtains at the windows, and everything was suspiciously clean for a railroad office. Before I could get out, however, a neat little woman came to the railing from behind a big desk and asked my business. I fuddled around like a boy, but finally made her understand I was looking for the trainmaster. T hold that po ition. What can I do for you?' I re- gained my nerve and told her I was look- ing for work in the train service and pulled out a bunch of letters and my card.

"She looked the letters over, and then said : "They are all right, but you are too old to enter our service as a new man ; the age limit is 35 ; and then, too, I see you wear glasses. You couldn't pass our color-blind examination at all. I'm sorry, but our rules are verv strict.' I then asked

order is 174,600 pounds, of which 136,000 pounds rest on the drivers. The driving wheel-base is 15 feet, and the total 26 feet 2 inches. The cylinders are 20 x 28 inches, and the driving wheels 75 inches diameter. The boiler is extended wagon top, with a working pressure of 200 pounds. The firebox is 1203-16 inches long by 41 J4 inches. There are 370 tubes. 2 inches diameter and 180 inches long. The tubes provide 2,889.85 square feet of heating surface, the water tubes 34.28 square feet, and the firebox 200.7 square feet, making a total of 3,124.83 square feet. The grate area is 34.63 square feet.

-■\t a recent meeting of an engineering society in London, a celebrated civil engin- eer made some remarks about the kind of railway structure that would be best adapt- ed to train speeds of 100 miles an hour and over. He advocated a good solid

SCHEXECT.ADY TEN-WHEELER FOR MICHIG.\X lEXTR.\L R.\ILR0.AD.

government business it was handling, and every employe was working overtime. Mrs. Pease wired repeatedly that the office was without a head, but no attention was paid to the communications, and meantime she handled the office lik a veteran. One day the superintendent of the division dropped into Gila Bend. The 'acting train- master' was having an audience with a big engineer who had carelessly run through on open switch. He sat, a grin- ning watcher, while the dainty little wom- an made the engineer squirm with her scathing comment on his neglect, and when -he told the big fellow he could take a thirty days' vacation to improve his eye- sight, the superintendent was evidently satisfied that the A. T. M. was 'on to her iob.' Before he left he told her that the genera! manager was so well suited with her conduct of affairs that he had author- ized her permanent appointment to the office.

"It was over a year after her appoint- ment that I came through Gila Bend, and I sought the trainmaster's office. I en-

for 'transportation' East, and this charm- ing little trainmaster turned to a black- whiskered individual at one of the desks, saying: 'Oliver, make this gentleman out a pass to El Paso. Railroad man looking for work.'

"When I got outside I learned that the dark-haired gentleman was the woman's husband. He had come back from Cuba as fit as ever for his old job. but 'the pres- ent incumbent' was giving entire satisfac- tion, and he had to content himself with a clerkship in his wife's office.

''Mrs. Nona Pease, of Gila Bend, N. M.,. is the only woman in the world who fills the position of trainmaster on a railroad." — Kansas City Star.

Michigan Central Ten Wlieeler.

The ten-wheel engine here shown is one of a group recently built by the Schen- ectady Locomotive Works for the Michi- gan Central Railroad. It was designed to pull the heavy fast passenger service, for which that road is noted.

The weight of the engine in working

track curved to a radius of about two miles. On a track laid in a series of very easy curves he maintained that a train was steadier than on a perfectly straight track and that the train resistance was not increased.

Messrs. Buker & Carr, Fairview Heights, Rochester, N. Y., have issued a little pamphlet which will interest air-brake men and others. It shows their hose stripper and cutter and the work that is produced by it. With this machine one man can splice SCO hose a day.

-At a meeting of the Institution of Me- chanical Engineers of Great Britain, a paper was read advocating the use of larger freight cars as a means of reducing the cost of transportation. There are few "wagons" on British railways that carry ten tons and these are confined to mineral traffic. In explaining the difficulties in the way of making a change one member stated that there are 500.000 cars belong- ing to private owners.

24

LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING

January, 1901.

The Tropenas Process.

The Sargent Company, of Chicago, have made a step in advance, from a metallurgi- cal standpoint, in their Tropenas process of making castings. Heretofore the vast majority of small castings have been sup- plied by the makers of semi-steel or cru- cible steel ; the former metal, of course, not having the properties of actual steel, and the latter being too expensive, while both of these processes necessitate con- siderable time for the turning out of even moderate sized orders.

By the Tropenas process they are able to manufacture small steel castings of ex- cellent quality, machine molded, and the larger the order the quicker the delivery in proportion. These castings do not require annealing, so that the day after the pat- tern is received at the foundry it is pos- sible to turn out a day's worlc, running from one to several hundred pieces, and the day thereafter the castings may be cleaned and are ready for shipment.

Notwithstanding that they have never hitherto advertised themselves as manu- facturers of small steel castings nor sought this business, they have had many orders for work of this character, which were formerly filled in crucible or open- hearth steel. It is through their experi- ence in the manufacture of steel by these two processes just named that they have been led to the adoption of the Tropenas process for small castings. Their plant is at Chicago Heights.

The Tropenas process was adopted after several years of experience with open- hearth and crucible steel plants, and after a careful study of the subject of steel-mak- ing at home and abroad, where the Tro- penas process is in successful operation in some forty different plants. It consists in the use of special converters, in which pig iron and selected scrap, previously melted in a cupola, are subjected to an air blast of 3 to 4 pounds pressure per square inch, directed horizontally across the top of the molten bath. This action generates in- tense heat by the combustion of the metal- loids in the pig iron, and after a period varying from sixteen to twenty minutes, depending on the quality of the charge used, there remains in the converter a bath of nearly pure iron. Addition is made of ferro manganese or ferro silicon, or both, to bring up the silicon, manganese and carbon contents to the specified pro- portions, when the metal is drawn off into a ladle and poured. The process is very simple and the product very regular.

Its peculiar advantage lies in the fact that the resultant metal is much hotter and more fluid than that produced by any other method, and it is this fact which makes it valuable in the manufacture of small and intricate castings, as it can be poured over the lip of the ladle in as small a stream as desired, and will run through thin sec- tions, producing solid castings free from pin-holes and cracks. Any grade of metal is readily produced by varying the addi-

tions. It is consequently valuable not only in the production of low carbon steel of the maximum permeability, so much de- sired in electrical castings, but also in the production of special grades of hard steel for mining-machinery parts and other pur- poses.

Miscellaneous castings, unless otherwise specified, ire made of mild steel, which is tough and machines readily, having a ten- sile strength per square inch of from 65.- 000 to 75,000 pounds, with an elongation of 20 to 30 per cent. The accompanying illustration shows a few of the castings made of Tropenas steel. They are solid and true to pattern, equalling in every re- spect forgings of all kinds, which they are intended to replace, as they can be fur- nished in much less time and at a lower cost, especially where special dies and ap- pliances for forging are made.

duce blast for a cupola is equal to three- tenths of the tons melted per hour multi- plied by the pressure of blast in ounces per square inch. For forge blast an allow- ance of % horse-power may be made per forge, and for exhausting smoke there- from the power required will be .44 horse- power per forge.

Machinery and Transportation Building

Progress in Pan-American Exposition construction is specially emphasized by the completion of one of the largest and most important buildings, six and one-half months before the opening date of the Ex- position. Machinery and transportation exhibits will be installed in this splendid building, which is a very striking and beautiful exhibit in itself. Description fails to convey to the mind the impression

THE TR0PEN.\S PROCESS.

Wherever possible, all patterns are molded by machinery, which insures uni- formity. Every attention is devoted to securing the best result both in quality and workmanship. All kinds of work in the shape of special castings for automobile construction, general railroad, mining, electrical and machinery parts, where lightness and strength are desired, can be made in Tropenas steel equal in all re- spects to forgings.

In his paper at the last meeting of the American Society of Mechanical Engi- neers, Mr. William Sangster presents some interesting facts regarding fan- blower practice in connection with cupola furnaces and forges. He points out that "in hardly any other class of machinery is the methods of application of so great im- portance as it is in the case of centrifugal fans. The conditions of one installation are usually so different from those of any other that hard and fast rules are out of the question." Briefly summarized, he shows that the horse-power required to pro-

upon the observer of such a triumph of architectural and engineering skill. It is one-third of a mile in circumference, every foot of which is replete with beautiful de- signs in columns, grills, panels and relief work, interspersed with such lavish colors as the Moors were wont to use to embel- lish their ancient mosques and temples. The building is not only grand; it is grandly beautiful. Present progress leaves no doubt about the Exposition be- ing ready on time.

Nearly all railroad officials legard the competition of street cars as an unmiti- gated evil ; but Mr. W. H. Newman, presi- dent of the Lake Shore & Michigan South- ern Railway, looks upon street car line ex- tension from a different standpoint. He rejoices to see street car lines extended into the territory of his road, because he knows that dwellings will be extended far beyond the city limits, and his company will gain more from hauling freight to provide the necessities of life for the peo- ple than they lose in passenger fares.

laanarr. 3001.

LOCOMOTI^^: engineering

Air=Brake Department

COWXCTED B^ F. JL ?«T1 ] tS.

Two-ApplicatiM Stop.

Freqnent inquiries from Gorrespoodems aad oranmmciatioDS trooi coairibntors seem to indicate that ihe term "mo-appli- cati<n stop" is not piroperiy tmderstood. Possibly this is becacs« of die insn&ien- CT of the definition; bowerer, we hope a better nnderstanding of the matter inaj be had from the following :

'^wo-appliolioa sicfi* does not mean that the stop shall be nsade bj two sodi resnlar apfdicatioas osnall j made to bring

lease p':;;"^-:-— ior 2. fejjcd or so. then immediatdT reramed to lap. This mores the triples to rdease position, and leaves the train line and anxiliarT reservnir pres- sores in conditioa for an immediate re- application which wiU be limner aad there- fore less liable to slide wfae^.

However, sfaoold the rdea% of the first application be made bv necesaty of con- ditiaas at a medinm high ^>eed. and a re- apfdication at the reduced pressore be doobtfnl of soffioent force, a retnm to

.owe<i, by otter tighter oacs nntfl : : is cedoced to a de- sirable i . .:: release, bmt do not re- charge. Reapply as conditions reqoire, and make final release shortly before train is brotiglit to a standstill, then recharge 10 rn?Ttmpm pressures.

A Xew Yoifc woman, little accustomed to traveling and nervous rather than other- wise. =3ys Leslie's Weekly, focnd herself

UK.Mlii.s £v^U'c%^ rx_-0»

a train from speed to a standstill — that is. diat two regolar applirations and two reg- nlar releases and recharges be made. That is not intended. The real inten- tion and recommended practice is to make a rather heavy redoctitHi. say. of- ten poimds. followed by fnrdier rediKtions. if necessary, tmlil ^eed is reduced to aboDt ten or twdve miles per hoar, then rdease. but do not recharge. The btake valve handle should be thrown to fnO re-

nmniiw positioa for a short period before finally retnming to lap preparatory to malring the rcapplicafion. would doubtless be a safe and advantageoos coarse. In either event, there would be no over- charged train pipe, and the pr^siire woold be equalized and in condition to get an immediate response from the brakes when die le^iplication is made.

The *^twt>-application stop" is then made as follows : A heaw initial redoctioa. f ol-

on the Empire 5"a"e express the other momii^ booad for Btiffalo. The train had hardly passed Tarrytown when the old lady asked the brakeman if there was any fear of an accident.

"Yes, ma'am." he replied, "plenty of fear, bnt no danger."

"TiSTiyr" asked the anxious woman

"Becanse every wheel has a high-speed air brake," was the reply.

"But. sir," she retnmed. feartnlly. -iap-

26

LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING

January, Ujoi.

pose sonietliing should get wrong with the air brake?"

■'Well, then the engine could be rever-;ed. and a pressure could be put on strong enough to kiep the cars from going into anything."

"But, brakeman." she replied, with deep anxiety, "suppose even that should give way, what would become of us all then?"

"Well," rciilied the brakeman, slowly, as if weighing a momentous question with all the care it deserved, "that, ma'am, would depend on the kind of life you'd been lead- in:. '

The high main reservoir pressure which is being carried to accomplish a full re- lease of brakes on rear end, causes the pump to labor hard, produces great heat, and is very hard on rotary and discharge valves. Only a slight defect in the dis- charge valve would allow the admission of a small quantity of hot compressed air. raiding the temperature in the air cylinder en -ugh to volatilize the oil (especially such oil as is generally used) and leave a deposit of carbon on the walls of the cylin- der, making the pump squeal and groan, ;inrl ilu- ili^cha'crv valve -tick.

This is proved in- the rapidity with which the main reservoir pressure is depleted when the brake valve handle is placed in full release pTsition. The real difference in main reservoir pressure and train pipe pressure immediately under the brake valve at time of full release, would doubt- le s be considerably less than the differ- ence in pressures taken on the first and tenth cars of a train. Keeping in mind the rapid depletion of the main reservoir pres- sure at time of full release, shown by the fwift downward travel of the red hand of the air ga;-;e. a more logical conclusion

SIX-C-\R THAIX HIGH-SI't:i

BR.VKES AT THE IiVTERN.-\TIi l.N'AI i i iRKKSl'nXDE.XCK SCHOnl-S. < llh ' STRUCTIVE EXHIBIT OF HIGH-SPEED BRAKES IN THE WORLD.

-rMiOUBTKlilV THE FINEST IN-

CORRESPONDENCE.

Suggested Enlargement of Full Release Port.

Editor:

In tracing the cause of,slid-flat wheels on trains consisting of from fifty to sixty- five air-brake cars (and often more), such as we are handling on our road, I think that the full release port in the brake valve is not large enough to admit a sufficient volume of air to reach the rear end of the train and releafe brakes, with dirty triples and bad packing rings, before the auxiliaries and leaks in train line use it up.

With a large release port in brake valve, of course the engineer would have to use care not to overcharge the train line when handling short trains.

M. M. Greenwade, A.-B. Insp. and Inst., Q. & C. R. R.

Ludlow, Ky.

[While the full release port in the brake valve is smaller than the area of a i-inch pipe, and is therefore a restriction to an absolutely free flow of pressure from the main reservoir to the train pipe, it is ex- ceedingly doubtful that increasing this port to equal the area of the train pipe would perceptibly improve results, much less remedy the trouble complained of.

and solution of the difficulty would be that main reservoir capacity is lacking. The trouble in this case is not that the full re- lease port is smaller in area than the com- bined areas of the feed grooves in the triples (supplemented by train-pipe leaks), and therefore unable to pass back main reservoir pressure into the train pipe a? rapidly as the feed grooves and leaks can absorb it ; but instead, is directly traceable to a failure to supply the train pipe with sufficient volume to hold the train pipe pressure higher than the auxiliary reser- voir pressure on the head end, long enough for the increased train pipe pres-ure to reach tlie rear cars. Brief-

January, 1901.

LOrOJIOTIVE ENGINEERING

^7

ly, tl:e full release port, altliougli smaller in area llian the train pipe, is sufficiently large to pass back main reservoir pressure inlo the train pipe as rapidly as a 75 or 100 (and even more) car train can absorb it. providing the main reservoir capacity i; in proportion to the needs of the train. This is proved on roads which handle 75 and ?o-car trains regularly. Of course, it train line leaks are so serious as to ab- sorb an unusual amount of main re-er- voir pressure sent back, and triples bad- ly neglected, the aspect changes, and the question then becomes one of repair and maintenance. A growing and bene- ficial practice nowadays is to put from 40,030 to 50,000 cubic inclios main rosi-r-

llic "fluttering'' of the equalizing piston when' making a service application. I would like to say that, in my experience wi.h a considerable number of brake valves, I have seen but one which had this characteristic, that one being in use on en- gine No. 206 on the Atlantic Coast Line. It is an F-6 (1892) model valve, and other- wise in perfect condition. R. S. Lee,

Roundhouse Furcman. Rockx Mount. .V. C.

when at the rear 01 a long train, but might shake things up considerably when n;ar the head end. Another triple valve was put en the car and would not apply quick action. Looking it over, we found the emergency piston bush loose and the port from the train pipe to the cylinder b'ockcd thereby. I send this in as I be- lieve i; may possibly be new and interest- ing to c:th?r readers of Locomotive Engi- Xi^KRiNG. S. P. Cole,

Nrcdtcs. Cal. A. & P. Rv.

Some Triple Valve Disorders.

Editor:

A triple was sent in here from Bar.-tow, account "going into quick action." Upon tvtins; rn the rack here, we found that

Refitting Triple Valve Packing Rings.

Editor :

In your October number under the head of "Testing and Repairing Worn Triple

EXCEI-r.ENTLY EQUIPPED I.\STRrCTION ROOM OF THE IXTERX.-\TIOX.\L CORRESPONDENCE SCHOOLS .\T CHIC.\GO.

voir capacity on all locomotives hauling freight trains over 40 or 50 cars in length. Si.xteen, twenty and twenty-four thou- sand cubic inches capacity main reservoirs were ample for average passenger and freight trains a few years ago ; but for the modern freight train, which has trebled, and even quadrupled, in train pipe length in the last few years, leakage increasing proportionately, more reservoir capacity — say 40,000 or 50,000 cubic inches — should be had to secure successful air-brake ser- vice on long freight trains. — Ed.]

A " Fluttering " Brake Valve.

Editor:

I noticed under Questions and Answers in December issue the feature in regard to

when the train pressure was increased rapidly, and then reduced, quick action would take place when about 8 pounds had been drawn off. We then tested for pack- ing-ring leakage, and found that by in- creasing the train pipe pressure slowly, we could release the brake and recharge the reservoir. By this I mean that the triple moved up so slowly that as soon as the edge of feed port was uncovered, its move- ment stopped. Upon examination, we found a slight shoulder worn on the bar- rel of the cylinder, and when piston was forced up to full release, it "stuck" ; but when pressure was increased slowly, it did not stick and the triple acted O. K.

Reasoning from the above, we can see that this valve would operate perfectly

Piston Rings," Mr. R. G. Shaffer asks that someone kindly furnish an article on this important operation. Some months ago this subject was discussed at some length by the writer in your paper and also at the Jacksonville meeting of the Air Brake Association last April. It is a well-known fact, and has proven itself very clearly, that the most vital part of the triple valve is the piston packing ring and its cylinder, and to effect the desired result, the work- manship must be as near perfect as it possibly can be made. This was proven by us some years ago when the company with which I am connected undertook to repair worn triple-valve cylinders, and after experimenting with several different methods, we were convinced that this

LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING

January. 1901.

work could not be done satisfactorily. So we abandoned the idea, and since then when it is found necessary to renew a triple-valve cylinder and packing ring, the triple valve is sent to the Westinghouse Air Brake Company for this work, and it comes back to us as good as new. We have just as good repairmen, as good ma- chines and as good methods as any road, and have made as good repairs as any road can ; yet we find the manufacturer c;;:. do the work better and cheaper than we can. For a time we resented the as- sertion that this could be done, but experi- ence has proved that it can.

i'. is sent to an eccentric machine where the packing ring is ground in its cylinder, for twenty minutes at the rate of 120 strokes per minutes. After this, it is sent to the test rack, where it is tested as to its efficiency and especially as to the re- lease of the triple.

It will be found much cheaper in the long run for railroad companies to send triple valves to air-brake manufacturers for repairs, as they only charge for such parts as are repaired or renewed. We are doing it, and know what we are talk- ing about. In my opinion, this is the best remedy tliat can be given for the grinding

of affairs to the lack of interest taken by those who come in contact with the work. In the June number of Locomotive Engineering is an article by J. J. Fleming on two application-stops ; also, on page 436 of October number Mr. Ettinger makes the statement that the engin- eers who do the smoothest braking are the ones who slide the most: wheels. We have pulled one of the fastest mail trains in the West, on a road which was competing with another road for the trans- portation of United States mail, and were compelled to take advantage of all con- ditions which obtained in order to make

THE IXfEKNATIONAL CORRESPONDENCE SCHOOLS' INSTRUCTION ROOM AT CHICAGO READY FOR A CLASS.

To appreciate the importance of this delicate operation of triple-valve repairs. it would be money well spent by any rail- road company to send their air-brake in- spector to visit the works of an air-brake company, to witness the manner in which the grinding of a triple piston ring is con- ducted, where it is perfect. The boring out of a triple-valve cylinder in the lathe should be discouraged, as this method will give very unsatisfactory results, as the cylinder will not be round and it will de- stroy the standard size of the cylinder. The air-brake companies . have necessary facilities for doing this work accurately, such as special grinding machines for making triple-valve cylinders perfect after they have been bored out in the lathe. The triple piston packing ring is then neatly fitted to its cylinder, after which

out of worn triple-valve cylinders and re- newing triple piston rings.

Otto Best, A. B. Insp. N. C. & St. L. Ry. Nashville, Tenn.

Two-Application Stops.

Editor:

I again receive Locomotive Engineering after an absence of six years. I note with interest the correspondence, especially that regarding the air-brake system and some of the peculiar questions asked. It seems that with the opportunities afforded by instruction cars, correspondence schools, and the number of years of experience, that the air-brake system would be pret- ty thoroughly understood by railroad em- ployes, but such does not seem to be the case. We can only attribute this condition

the time, and we did not fool with any two or three applications in making a stop. At a speed of, say sixty to seventy miles per hour, we commence in time and make a reduction of ten to fifteen pounds. Our speed line will run as in Fig. i. After the first release our train is drifting at the rate of forty miles per hour. The brake valve handle is thrown to full release posi- tion, and we "are carrying 90 to 100 pounds pressure in main reservoir. This pressure escapes back into thS train line and aux- iliary reservoirs. Taking into considera- tion the amount of excess pressure carried and the time that has elapsed from the first release until brakes are again applied, the Westinghouse gj^-inch pump will have train line and auxiliaries re-charged to nearly maximum pressure, consequently the danger of sliding wheels is nearly, if

January, igoi.

LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING

29

POt quite, as great with two applications as with one. The time lost by this mode of braking, in making, say eight or ten stops over a division, will amount to con- siderable and the fellow who makes the two-application stops will get left in the race.

Now, if the stop is made as in Fig. 2, there will practically be no time lost, and

First application

S 0

FIG. I. TWO- APPLICATION STOP.

First application

Partial release Stop

FIG. 2. TWO-APPLICATION STOP.

the danger of skidding wheels will be re- duced to a minimum. The greatest dan- ger of sliding wheels is in the last few feet of a stop. A full service application has been made, which, with a maximum pressure of 70 pounds, will represent about 50 pounds pressure in brake cylinders and auxiliary reservoirs, and not far from that in train line. The speed of train has been reduced to about 15 miles per hour. The brake valve handle is thrown to full re- lease position and another reduction im- mediately made. This action will allow enough main reservoir pressure to escape to train line to force pistons to full re- lease position ; but before brakes have fully released the second reduction again ap- plies the brakes; but pressure has been re- duced to such an extent that there will be no danger of sliding wheels, and stop has been made with practically one applica- tion.

Now a few remarks regarding air-brake instructors. They will commence with a set speech about port X communicating with port G, that connects with chamber B, etc., etc. If the student stops him to ask a question before he gets through with his song he gets "red headed." Engine- men have something more to think of be- sides the names of all these ports and chambers. All that is necessary for them to understand is the mechanism of the air-brake system, to locate a defect in any part of it and apply the remedy if pos- sible.

The instructor will get his class around iiim in the car and say, "Now, boys, we will make a fancy stop ; watch that gage and those pistons." IMakes a reduction of 3 to 5 pounds. Piston? all move out with exact nicety, and the instructor goes on to say, "Now, boys, that is the way to do braking, and do it right." Ptit Mr. In- structor on an engine with tliirty freight brakes behind him ; let him try his 3-to-5- pound policy, and he will stop at the next stati-n — maybe. Well, one of the boys

who has had a lot of this port X business pumped into his head goes out on the road with a train of thirty cars of air, that have been in service from one to twelve months since cleaning, and, as he nears a railroad crossing on a down grade of 60 or 70 feet to the mile, he makes his 3 to 5 pound reduction — and doesn't even see the crossing. It takes good judgment, considerable practice and a thorough un- derstanding of the air-brake system to do a good, smooth job of braking under any and all conditions.

D. B. HUTCHINS,

A.-B. Insp., K. C, F. S. & M. R. R.

Sfiringficld, Mo.

[The "two-application stop" recom- mended by air-brake men and recent writ- ers is exactly the same as the Fig. 2 stop described by our correspondent. The idea

passageway or valve is absolutely neces- sary where the subject is to be discussed intelligently, for frequently no valve can be obtained to place the finger on the part. The "sing-song," however, cannot be too severely condemned. — Ed.

Handy Air- Brake Tool.

lidilor:

The accompanying sketch is of a device which I have been using for some months past to remove the handle of the F-6 engi- neer's valve from the rotary key, and to lift the cap from the valve body.

As will be seen from the sketch, the nuts are retnoved from the rotary key, the clamp placed under the cap, and the set- screw screwed down on the rotary key. This causes the handle to slip off the key and the cap to lift from the valve body.

THE WESTINGHOUSE LATEST IMPROVED SLACK ADJUSTER — NOTE METHOD OF DRILLING HOLE IN BRAKE CYLINDER.

is. to make a stiff initial reduction and hold the application on until the train has been brought to a low speed, say s or 10 miles per hour, then release, but not re- charge. The second application, or "par- tial application," as our correspondent calls it, brings the train to rest with great- ly reduced pressure and less liability of wheel sliding. The principle is the same as that of the high-speed brake — the heavy braking is done with high pressure at high speeds, and low braking with low pressure

Thus the usual hammering and prying of the parts is done away with, the several pieces separating easily and uninjured.

I trust the device may be of use to those of your readers who have to take brake valves apart. M. Marea,

A.-B. Insp.. B. & O. R. R.

Garrett, Ind.

Another Recommended Lubricant for Brake Valves.

Editor:

I see several articles in the December and other recent issues of Locomotive En- gineering about lubricants for brake

marea S separating DEVICE.

at slow speeds. Air-brake inspectors should do as much road work as possible, and make their instructions coincide and harmonize with road work. To have a name, letter or numeral for each port.

16 Ihrcad DETAILS OF MAREa's DEVICE.

valves. As there seems to be a wide dif- ference of opinion as to which is best and as to the results, I would suggest that some of those having trouble try vaseline. I have used it for the past five years and

30

LOCOMOTIVE ENGINEERING

January, 1901.

always have good results. The brake valve always handles easily.

I think there is a great deal in easy handling brake valves in making nice, smooth stops. Try this once:. Clean out the air end of the pump with annnonia. give the brake valve a liberal application of vaseline, and you will have no more trouble with hard working brake valves. H. JNIuiR,

Louisvilh', Ky. Engr. So. Ry.

Device for Removing Reversing Valve Rod.

Editor:

I submit sketch of a useful device to air- brake men. Its purpose i, to raise the air- pump piston in the cylinder to such a posi- tion that the reversing valve rod can be re-

dJ

Fig.2

Fig.J

REVERSING VALVE ROD REMOVER.

moved. The hook on the end of the de- vice is placed under the top collar of the reversing rod, and the slide is slipped down over the end of the same rod. which holds it firmly so the piston can be readily raised. My method is to raise the piston about one-half the length of the cylinder, then clamp the piston rod between the stuffing boxes, which leaves it in position to remove and replace the reversing valve rod. The piston-rod clamp is made from an old pair of pipe cutters.

The tool should be 8 or 10 inches long to avoid steam from leaky throttle, and can be made from an old valve rod.

J. A. Jesson,

Nashville. Teiin. L. & N. Rv.

used at the Illinois Central shops, and is found very convenient.

W. W. Up De Graff. Cliicago, III.

Triple Valve Holding Device.

Editor:

The accompanying sketch is a stand used for holding triple valves in the vise while the valve seat is being faced. The stand is in two parts, A and B. B is held in the vise and A is placed at any desired angle and secured by set-screw, which has a hardened point D. This device is

Concerning Train Pipe Leaks.

Editor:

Among other things I notice in a recent issue of Locomotive Engineering is an answer to a correspondent who writes to inquire how the air could escape from the brake pipe and auxiliaries on a fifteen-car train without dragging the brakes suffi- cient to warn the engineer. In answering the question, the editor states that the air possibly leaked from brake pipe and auxil- iaries through the leakage groove in the brake cylinders, and that, should any of the leakage grooves be stopped up, those brakes would most likelj' have set.

There is another reason, not mentioned, and that is, so long as the leak in the brake pipe does not exceed the amount which can pass freely through the feed port in the triple valve, there will be no movement of triple valve piston, notwith- standing the brake pipe pressure should leak to zero.

It would be interesting, after charging the auxiliary reservoir, to make a slight leak in the brake pipe and note the action of the triple valve ; and to also note how fa-t the air can be taken from the brake pipe without getting a movement of the triple. The large plain triple, as used on driver brakes with large cylinders, will stand the greatest leak. The freight brake, owing to the small feed port, will stand the least leak from the train pipe without setting the brake. But even with our stan- dard freight brake, 50 pounds can be leaked from the brake pipe in twenty-five min- utes ; while at the end of thirty-five min- utes, but 10 pounds will remain in the brake pipe, and still no brake will set which has the feed port in triple valve clean. Forty minutes will bring the hand on the gage to zero pressure, and the brake with the leakage groove in the brake cylinder stopped up, will still remain un- set.

It therefore occurs to me that engineers should understand that the air in the brake pipe and auxiliary reservoirs can leak away without a practical warning caused by brakes dragging. Furthermore, it can- not be too strongly impressed on the minds of trainmen the danger of permitting leaks in brake pipe. O. B. J.

Detroit. Mich.

Forces and Conditions to be Con- sidered in Train Stopping.

Editor:

After reading the article by Mr. Whelan, page 531, December number, I regret my inability to recognize the relation that exists between the mud thrown oflf a moving wagon wheel by "centrifugal force," and the lack of adhesion between brake shoes and wheels at high speeds as compared with low speeds.

The mud taken up by the movmg wheel

TRIPLE valve holding DEVICE,

is given a rotary movement with a disposi- tion to fly oflf